 
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
|
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
In Reply to: How old are you anyway, Tom? posted by Audiophilander on May 17, 2002 at 15:03:18:
>>Unfortunately for the Star Wars saga, that first film seems to have aged much better than Lucas' ability to cast and direct his vision.<<1) He never had such ability to begin with. Take a look at his "illustrious" directing attempts other than star wars. Did you also happen to notice that Empire and ROTJ (the #1 and #2 films regarded by fans) are not directed by him?
2) The first films were panned by critics during their original theatrical release. Yes they've aged well. What makes you think these new 3 won't? Time will answer that question.
>>How old are you anyway, Tom?<<
I didn't check the release date of the original star wars before I posted my response. I was >1 year old when the first movie was released in 1977. I only saw the original on home video formats while the other "first 2" I saw in theatres after nagging my parents incessantly.
>>but when I go to see an overhyped mega-million dollar feature <<
And who created this hype? Who said it was going to the greatest thing in the world? Probably the same people who waited in line for 12 hours then left in the middle of the showing.
>>feature I do expect to be entertained without wincing at corny cliche` dialogue and bad acting. Note: If I wanted that, I would stick strictly with the serials of the 30's and 40's!<<
Hello!? What do you think Lucas has admitted to emulating time and time again? Why is this suprisingly offensive now? If you work off of preconcieved notions, you may be attempting to interact with something that isn't there (insert CG blue screen quip here).
Tom §.
Follow Ups:
I consider the first Star Wars a great film followed closely by The Empire Strikes Back. Even though he didn't direct the second and third features in the series, both were his "vision." Unfortunately, the wheels started falling off of that vision in the third film (i.e., it was to neatly tied up and had some serious "groaner" elements including the cute furry creatures that had TM marketing written all over them).FTR, Lucas was at one point in his life viewed as a great visionary director (even before SW) from the same class as Spielburg, Scorsese and others who came into prominence in the early 70's; of course, you are correct in your assessment that he hasn't lived up to those expectations.
As for what he is emulating, well if it's the serials of the 30's and 40's he is doing it badly or picking the worst ones to emulate. You may recall that Spielburg's Raiders of the Lost Ark also based it's theme and structure on the classic serials and pulled it off handsomely. Granted, Lucas had a hand in the concept, but Spielburg created a beautifully directed homage to a classic form of cinema that WILL stand the test of time. His second effort fell short and he recognized the fact that he'd let his audience down somewhat and corrected the failure by turning in another classic in the third film in the series.
My point here is that Spielburg has respect for his audience while Lucas is gotten wrapped up in the minutiae of creating special effects to the point where he no longer connects to the movie going public outside of the drooling SW fan base.
As I indicated your loyal fan above, may the farce be with you!
AuPh
> > My point here is that Spielburg has respect for his audience < <LOL! He panders to and manipulates the audience just like Lucas. He just pulls different strings. To me, the indy jones series is just as hokey as star wars. Although, It doesn't make it less entertaining.
Tom §.
... and far less hokey. Spielburg DOES pander to certain audience expectations dependent upon the type of film he's making, but as a director, Spielburg still has an artist's heart and coninues to redefine himself creatively; no such luck with Lucas.AuPh
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2024, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
