Audio Asylum Thread Printer

Get a view of an entire thread on one page

FAQ / News / Events

Films/DVD Asylum

I am as serious as Chirac.

63.176.25.63

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Thread: Display Email ] [ Films/DVD Asylum ] [ FAQ ]

In Reply to: Re:You must be jocking..... posted by patrickU on August 16, 2003 at 03:10:07:

Hallyday was GREAT. Understated performances are difficult. The eyes and the voice must carry the emotion, the pacing, and hold the interest of a jaded, violence-addicted, and semi-deaf audience. He did it. I could not take my eyes off him.
The character was, like Brando's in "Last Tango...", a middle-aged man in full realization of life's fragility.
The scene in the bar when he was barreled into, and let it slide, was brilliant. Can you imagine how Hollywood would have handled it? Remeber the scene in "Shane" when Ladd took on the entire gang w/his fists (Alan Ladd, for god's sake!) and the farmer came in to help him? Imagine that scene now with the teacher helping Hallyday?!!!
No, Patrick. It is YOU that have Hallyday baggage. You cannot separate a very mediocre rock musician from his acting---which in this case was brilliant. See it again and concentrate on him.

Follow Ups:

Re: Yet, you are wrong as Adolph..... - patrickU 07:05:23 08/16/03 (4)
Johnny " performance can only bbe " understated " as he is not capable of something else. The role was suited to him, but he could have done the opposite.Ladd ? of course I can..Ronald favorite film....
I discute this film with Victor. I was then better encline to it as I am today, particulary for the pseudo performance of Mr. Halliday.
Mediocre musician and more than that for acting. A propos acting how many films have you seen with him ?
At the moment there is an envistigation on him for rape, that may eventually happend two years ago, in my home town of Nice...One of the criminalist in charge has been expelled because of bribery, just last week.
I hope this experience will made a better actor... ( sardonic )
Non mon vieux, I never like him, and never will.
Believe me, You are wrong.
Ton impossible ami.
P.
- I saw him in "Iron Triangle," a film about Vietnam, and - tinear 10:23:21 08/16/03 (3)
  the only thing I remember is the fact he was in it, which is probably a good omen?
  He may be a bastard in "real life" and have his problems with women (Polanski, Errol Flynn) but he IS a talented actor.
  Of course, we can agree to disagree. (Wine consumption put off---merde---until tomorrow: my wife was ill yesterday and wants a full day of recuperation before the splendors of the Riesling.
  - Re: I saw him in "Iron Triangle," a film about Vietnam, and - patrickU 11:29:01 08/16/03 (2)
    My wish for a quick recovery to your wife.
    It won�t change your mind that in France is is not regarded as an actor...but mainly as a singer and thar very highly...from his fans.
    - Hey, Patrick, if Johnny were an American, he'd - tinear 13:40:47 08/16/03 (1)
      run for political office. Look at Ahhnie: iron pumper; actor; governor?
      - Re: Imposssible! The French... - patrickU 00:54:47 08/17/03 (0)
        
        In Reply to: Hey, Patrick, if Johnny were an American, he'd posted by tinear on August 16, 2003 at 13:40:47:
        
        Actually are only fond of " Les guignoles ( " some kind of muppets show ") Imagine the " sosie " of Johnny beeing President de la Republique......haha..

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Atma-Sphere Music Systems, Inc.

You can not post to an archived thread.