Films/DVD Asylum

Re: One million films sold = Good film.

217.86.11.43

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Thread: Display All Email ] [ Films/DVD Asylum ]

patrickU

(A)

In Reply to: It IS a beautiful film posted by Victor Khomenko on March 20, 2004 at 05:03:06:

I know, we already discusst it!
But I thing it is from A to Z a marvel, maybe you have to be from the South to feel the whole parfum of it?

Follow Ups:

Re: One million films sold = Good film. - Victor Khomenko 07:46:20 03/20/04 (10)
Hard to argue with personal judgements, of course, but I had the fortune to see both just a few days ago, a couple of days apart, and I would still maintain that the 8 1/2 is more perfect. Like you I simply love those tiny sub-plots, each one offering food for thoughts, and in the 8 1/2 they were joined a bit more perfectly together.
But all that minor criticism is of course at the already fantastic level - let's not forget we are comparing Fellini to Fellini, so the stakes are astronomical.
The only film by him that irritated me was the Satiricon, and it has been perhaps fifteen years, so maybe time to revisit it?
Did you like it?
Anyway, Fellini is all about poetry, he is not Dumas and not Dreiser - he is much more in the Pushkin vain. And if someone doesn't appreciate poetry then Fellini might not resonate.
- Satyricon was too contrived for me. I'll take Cabiria...nt - clarkjohnsen 10:59:04 03/20/04 (1)
  z
  - Jesus, talk about a no brainer! - Victor Khomenko 11:00:46 03/20/04 (0)
    Cabiria is a monument of a movie, a timeless treasure, simple and poignant in the extreme.
    One of the 100 best movies of all times.
- Re: One million films sold = Good film. - patrickU 08:23:18 03/20/04 (7)
  Yes. Absolutely!
  I have start to look at Satyricon for two minutes and was not in the mood So it is delayed...After my" Russian " period I will go for 8 1/2.....But the problem is Doris is looking at the TV a lot ( suddendly ) and did not have the courage to banned her in another room ( Dennis ) ....
  And yes.
  
  PS: You may scroll down to a post I send " A statement " as you nave have been called there more than once....
  - Done - Victor Khomenko 08:36:20 03/20/04 (6)
    But I am shivering with anticipation now... what if I fail to satisfy his enlightened request? What if I fall short of his expectations of me?
    - Re: Done - patrickU 08:40:37 03/20/04 (5)
      The only way I can think of is, as hard it is to me to tell you, my dear old friend is : SUICIDE!.
      Poor old chap, I may look after Anya, if it is your last wish...If not, just the same...
      What?...Oh yes...Beamer too! Ok.
      - You know... I somehow prefer RDA not talking to me. - Victor Khomenko 08:50:38 03/20/04 (4)
        
        In Reply to: Re: Done posted by patrickU on March 20, 2004 at 08:40:37:
        
        I don't know what his thing with Fellini is, but I suspect this is just the result of the trivial nihilistic tendencies - if something is acknowledged to be good, it is beneath some to like it.
        On one occasion a friend told Anya, who loves Bergman and FEELS him, that she only was saying she appreciated the artist because it was expected.
        She was furious, and for good reason. That man is nihilistic in other areas too - a Jew who refuses to cover his head in a sinagogue (he only attends when he has no choice - basically just the funerals).
        Some interesting psychological observations are always part of being involved into any hobby.
        
        Re: You know... I somehow prefer RDA not talking to me. - RGA 12:55:23 03/28/04 (0)
        
        In Reply to: You know... I somehow prefer RDA not talking to me. posted by Victor Khomenko on March 20, 2004 at 08:50:38:
        
        "I don't know what his thing with Fellini is, but I suspect this is just the result of the trivial nihilistic tendencies - if something is acknowledged to be good, it is beneath some to like it."
        Now that is the pot calling the kettle black. See reviews of Spielberg movies. -- At least 6 are acknowledeged to be better than good. Nihilistic tendencies - look in the mirror. More people like those 6 or a combo of them than 81/2 - If you want to bet your house I'll take it.
        
        Make that RGA... sorry. (nt) - Victor Khomenko 08:53:58 03/20/04 (2)
        
        In Reply to: You know... I somehow prefer RDA not talking to me. posted by Victor Khomenko on March 20, 2004 at 08:50:38:
        
        .
        
        Re: Make that RGA... sorry. (nt) - patrickU 08:59:58 03/20/04 (1)
        
        In Reply to: Make that RGA... sorry. (nt) posted by Victor Khomenko on March 20, 2004 at 08:53:58:
        
        You see that is just the differences between a real man and boy.
        A lot of people thinks if you cahnge your mind you are vulnerable, just the contrary is the case.
        Only the strong can change their minds.
        
        Only the weak - RGA 12:59:55 03/28/04 (0)
        
        In Reply to: Re: Make that RGA... sorry. (nt) posted by patrickU on March 20, 2004 at 08:59:58:
        
        base their opinions on what others tell them rather than independantly thinking. You post reviews of what others think to back up your arguements??? I then showed you that I can do the same from an opposing point of view. Get it?
        Probably not but oh well.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Kimber Kable

You can not post to an archived thread.