|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
In Reply to: Master & Commander. posted by patrickU on May 07, 2004 at 05:14:13:
I just cannot picture Crowe as a captain in the Royal Navy. Sorry. I also thought the relationship with his doctor was weak, ill-written, and trite.
Follow Ups:
Couldn't disagree with you more.
The dinner scene with the awful jokes and puns was simply pathetic.
That's the point, or one of them.They're taken straight from the books. The other officers are more amused at Jack's re-telling of these old jokes and Maturin's reaction to them than they are by the inherent wit of the material.
In Germany an France it did received very negative reviews!
Made me wonder how the Frogs aimed so damned well when they really weren't in visual contact but for a moment.
The French were renowned as accurate gunners.It was partly a lucky shot, calculating the British vessel's course and speed and last sighting.
As you may knows....
Should I now wait till you and Patrick settle this dispute between the two of you?It is, after all, my hard earned $3.25!
If you really wanted to see this movie you should have shelled out the 8 or 9 bucks to see it in a propper venue on the correct medium. I do not understand why people wait for video releases to see such visual movies.
There are people in places with decrepid theaters and/or who have state of the art Home Theaters who prefer to see a film there. My own sound system at least is FAR better than my local cineplexes. There are many advantages to home viewing.
It's still video.
Things you can do at home...
Any other things you don't understand?
To many to list.
so you may find some intellectual material to digest in various scenes.
If you are searching for a characterization of a man in a leadership position on a ship of HM navy...look elsewhere.
Specifically, the scene which was Crowe's one opportunity to display his great acting chops, the one in the officer's mess, was a total disaster. His attempt to tell an amusing story fell flat, with even the actors' in attendance unable to convincingly respond.
Compare that to Brando's skills as a raconteur in "Last Tango in Paris," especially the story about his having to clean the ditch...
Crowe is vastly overrated, though he was surprisingly good as the whistleblower in some film or other a couple of years ago.
(Patrick likes it because it portrays the French as clever AND brave).
During certain periods the French were not simply clever and brave, they were THE best.Rattles yor cage, that truth? He-he... you must have some non-French origin!
Lord Nelson was just a fluke.
My critic is absolutely correct. Donīt hear what foolish Tin and many critics have said on this film. You will see...Time will fly....
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: