|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
84.135.141.236
In Reply to: Re: I am afraid we speak two.. posted by Analog Scott on December 5, 2004 at 08:16:06:
Experience, which I do not doubt will not satisfy you! But it should spring to our eyes.
The problem will be inherently between us, hehe...As you certainly did find LOTR a film with qualities I did not.
So as you said, a difficult task.
I answer your question but with a "periphrase"...
Short I see no way to make this bet alive.
But if you find a possibility and some " rule of the game " I am, of course, in. As you maybe.
Follow Ups:
Experience? Who is that? *Someone* has to make the call if there is going to be any bet. If you wish to suggest a *person* to judge I'll consider your suggestions. Indeed we disagree on LotRs. But you are also at odds with many people with tremendous experience and knowledge in both film and literature. It's OK not to like something that is excellent like LotR and it is OK to like something that is dated and not really very good like the original King Kong. I like them both.
Many people...Hum...I would not hide between ANY people, as I rely on my point of view without been closed minded, I let always a place to misjudgement.
BTW, Bernardo did not like this film too, even we seldom agree on pictures, I must say he is right on this one...Hehe.
And then why would we not take him has a " judge " ?
If you are willing then we may have a bet?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: