|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
24.0.34.251
In Reply to: Re: War of the Worlds posted by rico on January 4, 2005 at 14:09:33:
(nt)
Follow Ups:
I'm pretty sure the original was in mono.All the original reviews of the Paramount CAV LD mentioned that the soundtrack was remixed for stereo.
http://www.dvdlaser.com/search/detail.cfm?ID=26134
I'm afraid I don't share the same rosey fondness for this film.
Sure it was a better film than When World's Collide but the CAV LD (I bought both back in '97/98 at the now-horrendous price of $45ea.)release of that film eclipses the rather poor presentation of WOTW.
The remastered Paramount CAV LD is sharper than the previous issue but is also blemished with many scratches and other markings on the source print, plus the
(Techni)colour palette had degraded so much that nearly every SFX shot showed up discrepancies wherein the color mattes had faded at a different rate to the main film stock.As for the stereo sound, it was distinctly nondescript and offered no real advantage over mono. The WWC mono track was far superior with better overall smoothness and a more solid, extended bottom end.
Someone mentioned The Shadow earlier on ?
It was released in a very good looking anamorphic widescreen Region 4 edition and possibly Region 2. Dolby Digital only, no DTS unlike the LD.
I'll be on the look-out for the Shadow (Region 2 or 4) in anamorphic WS for my nifty multi-region player! I was very disappointed that the Shadow DVD wasn't released in it's proper anamorphic aspect ratio here. As for War of The Worlds, it looks like the DVD may be the closest to the original release sound-wise; now I'm curious as to whether the technicolor negative has been sufficiently cleaned up and color balance restored through video remastering for the DVD to be a significant improvement over the LD.Cheers,
AuPh
Hi,There's no color difference between the WOW laserdisc and dvd; they appear to be the same source elements, although why the dvd was released in mono (very low-bit rate mono no less) escapes me.
The technicolor transfer runs to the browns (very common) but is excellent nonetheless. For EYE-POPPING Technicolor check out DR. CYCLOPS on LD. It's a 50's sci-fi cheeze-fest about a shrink ray, but it has the most intense technicolor I've ever seen (and I specialize in collecting technicolor movies).
The WOW was indeed released in TRUE STEREO for the roadshow prints; this was done to help compete against the threat of television by the movie studio; if you listen carefully to the WOW soundtrack you can hear a lot of out-of-phase material that gives a nice surround effect in stereo.
Watch for the authentic remake of WOW by Pendragon films coming soon; it's done in Victorian times and is true to Welles' novel.
BTW, Dr. Cyclops is an early 40's SF film (1940, specifically), which makes the survival and quality of it's 3 strip Technicolor elements seem even more impressive. I never owned the LD (wish I had, now); is it out or due out on DVD?Thanks for the updates, yo mama!
AuPh
x
;^)
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: