Films/DVD Asylum

Posted by Audiophilander (A) on March 29, 2005 at 11:07:12

In Reply to: Re: Beat it... posted by patrickU on March 29, 2005 at 10:16:39:

Road Warrior was merely sharing his impressions of the ACTING of Bruno Ganz in the film "Downfall" the conclusion being that it was a great performance worth seeing. The fact that the Director took some liberties with the film for dramatic impact isn't relevent to this discussion of the film's value artistically.

>>> "The film is mainly based of Hitler´s secretary memoirs, have you seen them? I did, long hours in front the TV. And this film show this. Almost every word in this film arestatement from witnesses." <<<

Do you disagree with the witnesses impressions or what? Your own words make little sense here.

Presuming that you've seen the film, which is a rather generous assumption in light of so many of your many cynical/critical postings (re: LoTR, et al), it's obvious that you don't share RW's impressions, which is entirely your right. However, your curt dismissal of his enthusiastic impressions of the film can only be seen as a dissing of his personal tastes; dislike the film or not, that snootiness in your posts, doesn't wear especially well.

>>> "My humility? Ha-ha!!!! ...
Go to your to the corner, and said 100 times...LOTR:::LOTR...." <<<

Have you seen all three LoTR films, and I mean the Extended versions, buckwheat! If not, YOU have no room to talk.

BTW, I'll agree with one point you've made here: In regards to your "humility" ha-ha is the ONLY appropriate response! ;^)

AuPh