 
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
|
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
68.37.240.251
In Reply to: Well that speaks of your taste in moies and ideas of mormality. posted by Analog Scott on August 17, 2006 at 09:13:00:
We could start easy, but on a truly idiotic note - the Hollywood (and American) obsesssion with winning underdogs.Face it... in real life someone beat into the pulp doesn't suddenly raise off the canvas to win the fight.
A quadroplegic does not jump out of his wheel chair to win a marathon.
If I were to count such events in American movies my computer would be smoking.
Normal? Hardly.
A janitor does not - in real life - become a mathematical genius. Not any more often than a 55 year old fart suddenly starts playing like Vladimir Horowitz.
Normal?
I could keep going, but that should give you some idea... it is not Frankensteins I am talking about... I am talking about fun for severely intellectually handicaped, forced by Hollywood on masses, and the masses willingly responding.
OTOH, all characters in Bergman's films are normal people... they find themselves in the situations that are common, but not any less interesting psychologically because of that.
Truth is, one does not need an abnormal situation to provide food for deep analysis - a family divorce and how "ordinary" people go through it is rich in emotions and psychology, in drama and revelations.
A quadraplegic winning a race is a sick joke, is a low brow entertainment for a dumb crowd.
Follow Ups:
"We could start easy, but on a truly idiotic note - the Hollywood (and American) obsesssion with winning underdogs.
Face it... in real life someone beat into the pulp doesn't suddenly raise off the canvas to win the fight."Actually it happens more often in real life than it does in the movies. Honestly some of the most outrageous underdog stories have only been deemed acceptable because they were based on real life events. The made up ones are rarely as unlikely.
"A quadroplegic does not jump out of his wheel chair to win a marathon.
If I were to count such events in American movies my computer would be smoking."
I must have missed that movie about the quadropalegic marathon runner. OTOH there was this guy that was dying of cancer who beat the odds, survived, and won a record 7 straight Tour de Frances. Try selling a made up story as unlikely as that one. Oh and there was this US hocky team back in 1980. That's just a couple. There are many many more real life stories. I get the fealing you are not much of a sports fan.
"Normal? Hardly."
Again it depends on yor defenition of "normal." Underdogs beating the odds certainly is normal enough to happen with reasonable frequency. The facts pove it. But if normal simply means average then no. But then movies have never exclusively been about average. Thank goodness.
"A janitor does not - in real life - become a mathematical genius. Not any more often than a 55 year old fart suddenly starts playing like Vladimir Horowitz."What movie was the 55 Horowitz in? By the way you are putting the cart before the horse. It was a mathematical genious that became a janitor because he grew up in a shitty envirement. Um yes that does happen. Ever heard of Einstein? No he wasn't a janitor he was a high school drop out and a clerk when he came up with two of the most important ideas in modern physics. Once again real life makes is stranger than fiction.
"Normal?"
depends on your idea of normal.
"I could keep going, but that should give you some idea... it is not Frankensteins I am talking about..."
if it wasn't then why mention Freddy and Jason?
" I am talking about fun for severely intellectually handicaped, forced by Hollywood on masses, and the masses willingly responding."
Actually I think you are talking about your personal taste in art and confusing it with an objective standard. Why not just complain about French impressionists because they don't paint realistic paintings?
"OTOH, all characters in Bergman's films are normal people... they find themselves in the situations that are common, but not any less interesting psychologically because of that."
Which is fine and I am glad his movies were made. but I would be quite sad if we were limited to his movies or that particular style.
"Truth is, one does not need an abnormal situation to provide food for deep analysis"
No truth is food for deep analysis is not limited to your concept of normality. really, how many of Shakespeare's characters or stories fall within your definition of normal? Or was he a hack?
" - a family divorce and how "ordinary" people go through it is rich in emotions and psychology, in drama and revelations."
It certainly can be if artfully portrayed. OTOH despite your prejudices a romp through outerspace or middle earth or an underdo's story can also be "rich in emotions and psychology, in drama and revelations." We as movie goers are enriched by the variety of vehicles for this.
"A quadraplegic winning a race is a sick joke, is a low brow entertainment for a dumb crowd."
I must have missed that one. Is a cancer survivor winning a record seven straight Tour de Frances a sick joke?
You two cojoined twins?
I accept your concession.
There is difference between a cheap shot and friendly joke... and my post landed under yours by pure chance - it could have very well been his!But I am sure you know what the crutch is, and a story with a crutch is a bad story. I had not been exposed to the crutched stories until I came to the US... believe it or not...
I didn't take your cheap shot as mean spirited. Sorry if it looked that way. Mostly I was disappointed that you blew off the content of my post. I'm still wondering about this quadropalegic marathon runner movie.
What is an is not a good story.... I don't know that you can pin it down. IMO almost any story can be good or bad depending on how it is told. Art is is the expression more than in the content. We can all spout basic truths, Life is precious, life is hard, love is beautiful etc etc. It means little just to say it. The art is in making us feel it in seemingly profound ways. I don't think there is a set of limits in terms of genre or story line in which this can happen. I can say "he layed dead in his mother's arms" and I can look at Michelangelo's Pieta. The content is the same. One can even argue the content is almost cheap and cliche. But I suspect you get my point.
Well, what you seem to be arguing that there is room for situations that normally do not happen in real life, or are improbable, and I am not denying that.My point was about the degree that such stories are present in the Hollywood movies. My impression is they are disproportionally presented. But when you start talking about things like disproportionate, that enters the subjective area, that is why I don't see much reason to argue about it. Heck, before coming here I would have hard time believing adults would be watching the James Bond movies, let alone the LoTR... cultural gap, I presume...
The quadraplegic remark was sarcastic, not meant to be taken literally, but I don't think you should deny that is a popular Amercan theme.
I don't see them dominating American movies.Not to argue. As you say it's hard to argue. I confess I never saw it as an American phenomenon but maybe it is. I would say that the majority of those films are sappy shallow and cheaply manipulative but there are some really good ones. Interestingly enough they are often refered to as "Rocky" stories. IMO Rocky was a great movie. It seems most people have forgotten that Rocky lost the fight. His victory was quite human, quite "normal." He found love. I can't remember any severely handicaped people going on to victory movies. But I don't see every movie that comes out.
"We could start easy, but on a truly idiotic note - the Hollywood (and American) obsesssion with winning underdogs"You mean like during the revolutionary war when those guys in tattered trousers, with almost no military experience, and little education, and mostly unorganized, defeated a larger force of well trained, well educated, well organized soldiers? You call it an obsession. What percentage of Hollywood films deal with the underdog? I guess I'd like to know what you mean by "obsession", because the overwhelming majority of Hollywood films I have seen seem to be obsessed with sex. But I know how you like boobies, so I guess that is okay.
I dunno, Vic. I happen to believe that the "underdog", that guy that starts with little in the way resources, and possessing nothing but determination, can excel beyond what someone one means can separates this country from any other. Perhaps that is why other countries' films generally do not tell those stories - because in those countries, it is not their reality.
"Face it... in real life someone beat into the pulp doesn't suddenly raise off the canvas to win the fight. A quadroplegic does not jump out of his wheel chair to win a marathon. If I were to count such events in American movies my computer would be smoking."
'Fraid I missed those films. Maybe you mean Rocky. But that is but one example. Painting with a very broad brush. You mean there really was a film where the quadrapalegic won a race? Perhaps you would point me in their direction. If your computer starts smoking, e-mail me the bill.
"A janitor does not - in real life - become a mathematical genius"
I think I know the film of which you write. You have it backwards. The mathamatical genius became a janitor. He was a mathamatical genius before he was a janitor. His genius was discovered while he was a janitor. Has it never happened that a person of great gifts, for whatever reason, has been in a profession that does not fully utilize their skills? Never? Ever? Perhaps communist Russia avoided such problems by telling people what their gifts were, and herding them accordingly.
"OTOH, all characters in Bergman's films are normal people... they find themselves in the situations that are common, but not any less interesting psychologically because of that."
"Truth is, one does not need an abnormal situation to provide food for deep analysis - a family divorce and how "ordinary" people go through it is rich in emotions and psychology, in drama and revelations."
Maybe. Maybe not. But have you ever watched a film merely for entertainment? To enter a different world? Have you ever had the pleasure of watching a film with your child, knowing that while the film maybe a little absurd, it is simply fun.
My three year old and I recently watched "The Polar Express" together. It was a joy and an experience that I would not trade for free copies of all Bergmans's films. Likewise when we watch The Wizard of Oz. In your zeal to exclusively watch realist films at the expense of escapist entertainment, for while there is time in life for both, it appears that some priceless moments may have passed you by. If I miss a "realist" Bergman film to watch Polar Express with my son, well, I am more than happy with the choice I made. And more importantly, so is he.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2024, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
