|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
71.110.251.61
In Reply to: Saw the Departed last night. posted by Ross on October 29, 2006 at 07:47:26:
and you would be amazed at the directorial "license" he undertook to mangle the plot and spirit of the original.***PLOT SPOILER for the original****
The Walberg character does not even exist in the original, and of course, the last (forced, Hollywood-typical) scene does not exist. Yup, you-know-who does not die in the original. In the original, morality issues do not get ironed out so neatly by the director.
Oh, yeah, the love triangle does not exist in the original, and the adultery scene in Scorsese's version is soooo typical Hollywood. No such thing in the original...
Follow Ups:
Great entertainment flick.I also think TD is a hugely entertaining adaptation and spin on IA.
I don't think either is a "great work of art" a la Rules of The Game or L'atlante or Third Man or Red Shoes or Sunrise or Tokyo Story or...
You get my drift.
typically American cuisine: add massive amounts of salt, then equal amounts of sugar to counteract, then a paleful of MSG: voila!
If you know where to go.
of thousands eat or what 299 million chow down on?
Both Coke and apparently this film (which I will likely not see until on free cable) are perfectly designed for their intended purpose.In that sense those "shortcomings" are not shortcomings at all, they are attaractions put there in order to increase the sales.
"free cable." You can be locked up for that, you know?
.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: