 
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
|
|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
69.136.244.80
In Reply to: Desert Island Weekend posted by afilado on March 15, 2007 at 22:52:44:
Only one Tarkovsky, and easily not his best. I do like some films on your list. But an interesting things happened to the Ark... I decided to take the second look, and that time it did not do too well. Maybe I love Hermitage too much? Can't wait to walk through it again in a couple of weeks.Thank you for posting it, lists like this tell us about each other.
Maybe tin would post his next? I think I know him well enough, but would be interesting to see how HE sees his favorites... I know his tilt...
Follow Ups:
are Watching Us," "The Bicycle Thief," "Miracle in Milan," "Marriage Italian Style," "The Garden of the Finzi-Continis," "The Two Women," and a few more.
I forget if you've seen "The Children are Watching Us." To me, it's as powerful as "Hidden Games."
I'd m a y b e put Antonioni ahead of Fellini, too, though I hate this type of exercise because it's like comparing great wines from different vintages or different varietals. It's interesting though because it stimulates sharing opinions and conversation.
Yes, I saw the Children, and I hate to be putting great movies in ranks... to me the Games is still more involving, but this might be personal. Ditto for those great directors. I am just glad all three of them worked and lived.You forgot to mention De Sica's one before last and wonderful Una Breve Vacanza.
Victor, most of these were impromptu, emotional choices. Intentionally, I gave little thought to any qualitative measure. I guess I'm just lucky to possess a natural good taste. ;~) The list could easily have included 29 different titles. I was just trying to be true to the challenge, without referring to some "best of..." list.
I am still absolutely baffled by aspects of the Tarkovsky and of "The Ark". "The Sacrifice" shows great humanity to me. These two and "Waitng For Godot" were intellectual choices. To challenge my mind while on the island. Again, three others could have sufficed.Strange thing about Kubrick is that my regard for his work has not held up over the years. He's still a favorite but I've begun to detect a detachment in his films that I'm surprised at having to accomodate. Still, "Dr. Strangelove" is on my list.
As for Fellini, much as I admire him, he just doesn't touch my heart in the right way. "8 1/2" is in my queue but I fell asleep recently watching "Nights Of Cabiria".
On my desert isle, I'll take one of my cheaper choices above. For instance, "Wild River" is most ordinary; I chose it because as a 13 year old I fell in love with Lee Remick in that film. It's my only nostalgic choice.
I love Russia and Petersburg, and the Hermitage. I suffered one of the world's greatest embarassments while once pursuing my beautiful ex-wife through the museum. Russia is a most foreign place.
You should give it another shot. It's another one of those funny, heartbreaking but ultimately a celebration of the human spirit, films.
Don't piss on my shoe and tell me it's raining.
nt
.. I'm gonna give it another try.Antonioni is my current favorite Italian. I'm seeing new things in his work, so it may work for Fellini.
Do you have a heartfelt list? No fair peeking elsewhere., To insure spontaneity you've got 24 hours. LOL.
and in no particular order.Rashamon
Dr. Zhivago
Paths Of Glory
Dr. Strangelove
Network
Badlands
Wings Of Desire
The Bicycle Thief
The Return
Last Temptation Of Christ
The Unbearable Lightness Of Being
Lovers Of The Arctic Circle
The Garden of the Finzi-Continis
The Thin Red Line
The Mission
The Last Wave
The Barbarian Invasions
Chariots Of Fire
Contempt
Harold And Maude
The Royal Tenenbaums
Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind
Solaris (just saw this)
Nobody Knows
Ashes and Diamonds
Tony Takitani
Don't piss on my shoe and tell me it's raining.
you've shown me new things to look into.I love it that you included Badlands. The Mission is an interesting choice; I need to see that again. The Royal Tenenbaums (what wacky, lovey fun), Lovers Of The Arctic Circle, The Last Wave, The Garden....This is a very personal list. And useful. Thanks.
-
The Mission I included for the music, cinematography and just the feeling when the Indians come out with the cross and are shot down.Badlands is all about the feel (could've easily included TM's other two movies for the same reason).
I don't think Lovers Of The Arctic Circle was particulalry well reviewed but it struck a chord with me. I could also easily have included Sex And Lucia also by Medem (and also not SO well reviewed) but I like his style.
Another movie I almost included was Frances. Don't know how I'd feel today but that was the first time I saw a movie and left feeling devestated.
Don't piss on my shoe and tell me it's raining.
I appreciate not having the "Best XXX" title, it is much more personal without it.I would not go on that darn island without a couple of Kubricks - his Paths of Glory and Barry Lyndon. The rest I could do without... for a while.
I would also make sure My Fair Lady was there waiting for me, and the Breakfast at Tiffany's was served.
Fellini is my long time love, not sure why it is not working for you, as he is a true poet. La Strada and Nights of Cabiria for starters.
We forgot Bergman, of course. Either the Seventh Seal or the Ullmann directed Faithless.
Among the musts... Forbidden Games, La Grande Illusion, L'Atalante, Profession: Reporter, Ivan the Terrible, Tony Takitani, Il Posto, It Happened One Night, and.... and... and many others.
Like you, I just reached quickly into my memory... aren't we lucky there is so much there?
Ah... almost forgot! Borat! As the sore reminder of why we are on that island in the first place!
..are up next. I just noticed that "Persona" arrived. I wish it would rain, or snow.
... about the absence of movies carried by women. For the life of me I couldn't unforcefully name one which is naturally close to my heart. You named a couple quickly, and I agree that they are deserving of high praise.I think I'll start a new thread.
springtime St. Petersburg.
You're a lucky man.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2024, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
