Films/DVD Asylum

Posted by yata on December 22, 2001 at 10:55:40

In Reply to: 4 stars for newbies posted by Harmonia on December 22, 2001 at 09:27:39:

I wasn't sure how the ring really worked. The fact that it would affect Frodo much differently than Bilbo confused me. Bilbo's inclination to evil was understandable from the beginning of the movie and at the elve refuge where he showed the hideous face to Frodo. Why didn't he use the ring all of the time of his possession if he craved so much for it? I guess I just have to read the book. You can never have plot holes in a book. :)

Overall, great cast. Love scene was in haste and underdeveloped. Maybe just an extra ten minutes of dialogue would do.