|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
In Reply to: A/V Preamp posted by Ron on October 28, 1999 at 21:16:33:
I was thinking receiver vs separates too. So I compared the Denon 5700 to Rotel separates costing $4500 (985, 991, 983 I think). The sound was quite different and at first I thought the wires were crossed and the left and right channel were switched between the two setups. Then I realized that the difference was in fact a 3D effect and my brain was confused because I was expecting a small difference and it was a huge difference! The separates gave a three dimensional effect to the music and the Denon gave a flat "soundstage." I was amazed. This was no Pepsi challenge! I used blind, double blind, mulitple variables (two different CDPs, setups, different rooms, cables, etc.). The speakers were Martin Logan Aerius-i by the way, which are closest to the Magnepan 1.6QRs I have on order. I was listening to the receiver and separates in stereo 2-channel mode because I think that is more critical than movie soundtracks. The music was classical, jazz and a little rock.I don't know why there is such a difference but I urge you to listen for yourself. I also auditioned the Classe pre/pro and amp combination for $5000 and will probably go that way rather than Rotel. I hope you can get a good audition too, because that's what you really need.
Yes, I believe separates are the way to get the best processing. Denon's 5700 is a great unit, but it really lacks the dimensional processing. I am considering the Sony TA-E9000ES processer....fairly well rated in Audio magazine...I believe it was the April issue. There are lots of Lexicon DC 1 units available on Audioshopper cause owners are upgrading to the MC 1. What do you think?
There is a Lexicon dealer here but no Classe. I am ordering the Classe in a couple of months and I could compare then, but I won't have a used DC1 comparison. Some people rave about Lexicon and others pan it badly. Nobody pans Classe. I am just hoping it will work out. Lexicon, in my opinion might be good but the DC2 is really spendy (5K?) The Classe for $3K seems like good quality for medium price. Everything else is $4-5K+. Can't answer your question, really.
The Classe is a good unit. Also consider the EAD TheaterMaster Encore (also $3k) and Theta Casablanca. These are all a distinct step up from the Rotels of the world.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: