|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
I have the ability to purchase either the Pioneer dv-37 or Denon dvd-1600 at around the same price, but I am not sure which one to go with.
I am leaning towards the Denon due to the reviews that I have read. Please advise.
Follow Ups:
Thanks to all for their reply's. I decided to go with the Denon 1600.
I have had it for a couple of years and have never had a problem. The image quality is excellent. I looked at replacing it with the Denon 2800 mkII model and I found the older Elite a much better DVD player. Image quality is excellent while the Farjouda equipped Denon was average in my opinion. With the Denon you do get a current model and you will get DVD-Audio with the Denon which might make it a better audio machine. For 100 bucks more than the Denon 1600 you can get a DV-47ai from J & R during their sales (649.00). This will blow away the 1600 in every way.
I've never seen the picture from the '37, so I can't comment directly. While I don't know what the author's experience is, when I read something like, "the worst chroma upsampling," it's probably a significant fact. I came across this review while doing my homework:"It also is an improvement on the previous elite models, the DV-09 and DV-05. Unlike them, the DV-37 has no significant chroma delay, and the ringing is improved. That said, we were still disappointed with this player. It has the worst chroma upsampling artifact of any of the players we have reviewed so far. We couldn’t imagine how someone could watch "Toy Story" on this player and not notice the jagged streaks on almost every red object in the movie. And, we noticed the problem on almost every movie we used in the testing, even when we weren’t looking for the problem. The red streaks were that bad."
My Pioneer Elite DV-05 failed on me twice, so reliability obviously wasn't one of the more important design concerns. "Elite" my ass. I haven't read many positive things about Pioneer players, so this is probably a shared experience.I've had the Denon 1600 for just under a week now and I'm really impressed. I use a projector with an 8' screen, so picture faults and digital artifacts tend to be really obvious... but they're not apparent with this player! (Gotta love the trickle-down effect, it also benefits from Faroudja technology.)
-Frank
-Frank
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: