|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
151.205.187.91
In Reply to: Just bought our first wide-screen LCD TV--and we hate it posted by bigi on September 1, 2005 at 02:46:04:
especially the bit about native resolution. A 1280 X 720p native LCD used with a good HDTV tuner and scaler can actually be very good. The scalers built into the sets themselves are variable.But LCD still has greater inter-pixel gaps than DLP and much greater than DILA (the old Hughes Light Valve, considerably improved.)
Contrast is also a bit reduced with LCDs as well, though they are much improved.
Plasmas and the new technologies under development are improving by leaps and bounds and may eventually surpass a perfectly calibrated CRT. But for my money, at least with a very good signal, they haven't yet. And LCD and DLP certainly haven't. They remain, however, an inexpensive entre to the experience. My flatpanel stays in the bedroom (an Aquos) and is excellent for more casual viewing.
However, the front projector is still the serious viewing choice for me. I must say, however, that it too is LCD. Ever since I sold my CRT front projector (much more film-like image than any digital but a royal PITA) I have stayed LCD because rainbows and orange-reds of DLP bother me and because they do not yet make a 92 X 52 inch plasma. I have never (in more than 5 years) had a dead pixel, poplar opinion to the contrary.
Both displays are 1280 X 720p and are coupled with an excellent scaler. They are fed by cable.
Your problem sounds like a combination of a marginal signal (or antenna), a mediocre tuner and a less than good scaler. OTA HDTV reception is more of a problem than most think. I know, I tried (though Manhattan is horrendous). I have none of your problems on either LCD but I know other Manhattanites who persist in the OTA HDTV effort. They are always complaining, no matter which display technology they have.
Follow Ups:
I still have a Barco 9" CRT front projector and I wont give that up until digitals can have an equal or better black level, no screen door or rainbows and cost less than a car and replacement lamps that cost less than an engine rebuild. Every so often I go out and look at the newesr digitals and granted they may not always be set up properly but I have yet to see anything I'd be able to live with at home after being spoiled by the Barco. Its gone for years now with only one repair needed and occasional convergence touch ups and I have 2 sets of extra crts to keep it running for years to come. I will only give up the Barco when digitals are equal or better and about $3000 or less with longer life lower priced bulbs.
I would not consider a plasma until they get the lifespan better. The lifespan of the brightness they put out is alogrythmic. I know people that bought them and ran them cranked up high like in the stores and after just several months the brightness plumeted and they are non repairable, throw away units.
but I already have one major tinker (vinyl) and one is enough.I have a friend with a Zenith 900 Pro which I love . . . I go over and watch, he keeps it tweaked. Rather like a neice or nephew (or a grandchild) you get all the fun of being around them for short bits; then you send them home.
This is the chip powering the new LG LCoS TVs just coming on the mkt.http://gom5.com/HDTVPresentation.pdf
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: