Duncan Shepherd on I, Robot -- Hilarious... - clarkjohnsen - Films/DVD Asylum

Films/DVD Asylum

Movies from comedy to drama to your favorite Hollyweird Star.

Duncan Shepherd on I, Robot -- Hilarious...

clarkjohnsen

...remarks towards the end.
I, Robot is but a travesty of the science fiction of Isaac Asimov, who pretty much wrote the book on robots, and not only the book of this name, a seminal collection of short stories. Filmmaker Alex Proyas (The Crow, Dark City) retains Asimov's Three Laws of Robotics, and -- from the novel The Naked Sun, second in a series of four -- the locked-room mystery of a roboticist's murder that may have been perpetrated, or at any rate not prevented, by one of his own robots, in clear contravention of the First Law. (To quote in full: "A robot may not injure a human being, or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.") The film has done away, however, with the android cop partner who would continue through the entire tetralogy, even beyond the life span of the human partner, and has instead fixated on a Dirty Harryish lone-wolf detective who, from the outset, carries a boulder-sized chip on his shoulder: "Can a robot write a symphony? Can a robot turn a canvas into a beautiful masterpiece?" (These are some of the concerns of an atavistic he-man in Converse high-tops in the Chicago of 2035.) Ensuing developments are more in line with the vision of the original literary inventor of robots, Karel Capek -- a table-turning revolt of the slaves against their masters -- in the stage play of 1920, R.U.R. (A play, by the way, that Asimov deplored.) In place of a bona fide science-fiction classic, then, we get just another one-week box-office wonder, another summer showcase for the swaggering and "styling" of Will Smith, another state-of-the-art portfolio of computer-generated imagery, another wave after wave of overscaled action. The repeated sight of identical robots duplicated on screen ad infinitum somehow seems to symbolize a very different and much more immediate threat to the future of humankind: the manufacture of interchangeable Hollywood blockbusters. Another and another and another and another....

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Topic - Duncan Shepherd on I, Robot -- Hilarious... - clarkjohnsen 07:41:39 07/22/04 (12)

Sorry, but it wasn't that bad, Shepherd's opinions notwithstanding; how about your's? - Audiophilander 10:22:08 07/22/04 (9)

Minority Report - great, I, Robot - v. good, MIBII and WWW - horrible.(nt) - mkuller 21:55:18 07/22/04 (7)

Re: Right on! - rico 02:38:46 07/23/04 (0)

With the exception of Minority Report, we're pretty much in agreement. - Audiophilander 22:55:08 07/22/04 (5)

Another way to watch minority report - Bulkington 09:53:40 07/23/04 (4)

Hi Bulkington. Please tell me what you think... - orejones 11:28:16 07/23/04 (1)

Huh - Bulkington 06:59:21 07/26/04 (0)

The whole eyeball thing was over the top and so implausible as to be laughable. - Audiophilander 10:39:54 07/23/04 (1)

Good crits. - Bulkington 13:22:59 07/25/04 (0)

Re: I, too, enjoyed it - rico 12:04:29 07/22/04 (0)

I was tired and slept through the final 15 minutes . . . - albee33 08:22:53 07/22/04 (1)

Wish I could say that about Harry Potter II and LOTR II. nt - clarkjohnsen 13:23:22 07/22/04 (0)

You can not post to an archived thread.