I finally was able to see this Korean film last night. It is the story of a Buddhist monk, living alone on a lake in the mountains, raising a young "budding" (?) monk. The film starts in the Summer, as the young boy torments a fish, frog, and snake by tying a rock to them and watching them struggle. The old monk sees this, then in the middle of the night, ties a large rock to the young boy, and tells him that he will remove the rock only if he finds the critters and removes the rock from them. However, if any are dead, then the rock will remain in his heart for the rest of his life. The boy searches to find the fish and snake dead.Spring finds him older, I suspect in his late teens. A young girl comes to visit the old monk to be cured of an unstated ailment. After a little while, the young girl and the budding monk are engaging is very un-Buddha like acts. The old monk warns the young man that these thoughts can create emotions which lead to murder. The young girl is cured, and so the old monk sends her away. The young man's passions having been roused, he leaves as well.
Fall arrives. The old monk now has a cat. He arrives with a package of fish wrapped in newspaper. The paper contains a headline of a man who has murdered a woman. It is the former budding monk. He arrives back shortly thereafter, a much changed man. More violent. Much more aggression. The old monk beats him, ties him up over the floor. Then takes the cat's tail, dips it in ink, scrolls over the outside deck. He then hands the older man a knife, telling that carving out the symbols will release his anger. Shortly thereafter, two police officers arrive to take the man into custody. They respect the wishes of the monk, and allow the man to continue the carving. When he is completed, the monk and two police officers color in the carvings. The policemen and the man leave, presumably taking him to jail.
Winter arrives. The lake is frozen over. The man returns now to an empty house with gray in his hair. He has been to prison. He has learned martial arts. The old monk has left his clothes, which the middle age man now wears. Arriving shortly is a woman whose face is completely covered with a cloth, and who brings a small baby. She appears to meditate in front of the Buddha statue. In the middle of the night, she walks upon the ice, and falls into a hole, leaving the baby.
Spring arrives. The baby is now a young child, and the man has assumed the position of the old monk, teaching the child. The cycle is complete. Did the old monk go through the same experiences? Role credits.
There is so much more about the film that is decribed here. This is one of the most perplexing films I have ever tried to decribe. So little actually happens, but so much happens. The best I can say is that it is almost like a religious experience, trying to define what cannot be defined. For example, one of the last shots shows the lake and cottage from mountains, and it almost looks inpenetrable (sp). Yet two police officers, a young girl and her mother, and a young lady and her baby make it there. The young boy takes the boat to the shore, yet the old monk is there with him, yet not wet. And there is only one boat. They never fish, have no gardens, yet are never hungry. The film is such a visual delight.
Am I recommending this film? This is one of the most moving films I have ever seen. It is, if nothing else, spiritual. If you like "artsy", if you need to analyze films from a techinical point of view, if you needs answers and logic, then the film may not be for you. But if you like to succumb to the moment and let a film simply absorb you, there is not a better film. A film I will not soon forget, and one of the best I have seen.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter, ... and Spring - jamesgarvin 10:27:43 08/05/05 (14)
- A horrible, pretentious, pseudo-spiritual crock. Sure to be liked by those who find Tarantino "deep." - Donald 22:35:30 08/05/05 (4)
- Re: A horrible, pretentious, pseudo-spiritual crock. Sure to be liked by those who find Tarantino "deep." - jamesgarvin 15:58:53 08/07/05 (0)
- And for balance, here's Tony Ryans taken to task for taking Kim Ki Duk to task.. - PCL 08:58:59 08/06/05 (0)
- Nice link: it works as fine as your subtle mind... (nt) - orejones 01:24:27 08/06/05 (1)
- Sorry about the busted link. - Donald 11:39:37 08/09/05 (0)
- Kim Ki-Duk - Jon L 15:51:23 08/05/05 (0)
- An excellent film though it suffers from the - tinear 15:49:06 08/05/05 (1)
- Re: An excellent film though it suffers from the - jamesgarvin 16:14:03 08/07/05 (0)
- Saw it in the theatre -- you barely do it justice. (That's not an insult.) - clarkjohnsen 11:42:31 08/05/05 (2)
- When I chose it on Netflix they recommended The Return. nt - sjb 13:02:01 08/05/05 (1)
- Imagine that. nt - clarkjohnsen 08:14:09 08/06/05 (0)
- Never heard of it... but it's now at the top of my Netflix queue. Thanks! nt - sjb 10:55:55 08/05/05 (0)
- Wonderful! Thanks for sharing... (nt) - orejones 10:44:54 08/05/05 (0)
- Its now on my list to buy (nt) - Jack G 10:43:39 08/05/05 (0)