In Reply to: Attention Superman fans posted by padreken on May 30, 2002 at 13:31:30:
... sucked pond water from the get-go! Everything about the first Superman movie was a disappointment, with all due respect to the acting efforts of the now wheelchair bound Christopher Reeves who essayed the role in each of the major films. In short, it's a sad day when the best thing you can say about a film is that it has a decent cameo appearance by Marlon Brando! If you want to see the Superman role done right (as well as the careful building of Lex Luthor as a villain in an inventive re-envisioning of the concept) watch Smallville on the WB; it's superb!Unfortunately, DC hasn't fared too well in it's characters depictions on the silver screen. The first two Batman movies were a little better than the Superman series of films due to inspired direction, but here again, by focusing on the "STAR" aspect of those actors portraying the villains the Batman concept was irreparably weakened. Any time the costumed hero takes a back seat to the scenery crunching of high-dollar actors broadly portraying villains it lessens the interest in the featured character and the story itself IMO.
Spider-Man got it right, as did the X-Men earlier. Sorry padrekan, but it looks like we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one.
AuPh
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Apologies in advance for differing with you on this, but the entire Superman series... - Audiophilander 15:18:49 05/30/02 (20)
- Hey Guys I Hate To Be A NitPicker, But.... - AudioHead 09:42:48 05/31/02 (4)
- LOL! Well, as you can see below, I concur! - Audiophilander 10:11:07 05/31/02 (3)
- Bud Collyer, I Believe. Yes? <Nt> - AudioHead 10:33:39 06/01/02 (2)
- Yep, I do believe you're correct; give that man a seegarr! :o) - Audiophilander 23:05:44 06/01/02 (1)
- A Few Years Ago, I Consulted A Superman Site.... - AudioHead 13:35:51 06/03/02 (0)
- Re: Apologies in advance for differing with you on this, but the entire Superman series... - mikenyc 01:19:25 05/31/02 (4)
- IMHO, Spidey holds up better than the poorly envisioned DC Superman/Batman "epics" - Audiophilander 06:24:22 05/31/02 (3)
- Batman "epic" done right - Alan Breece 07:52:46 06/04/02 (0)
- Spidey holds up better ? - mikenyc 21:10:18 05/31/02 (1)
- Well, Spidey only improves with age; sort of like a decent vintage/vinyard Cabernet. - Audiophilander 01:16:08 06/01/02 (0)
- No apology necessary, Auph! - padreken 15:49:41 05/30/02 (9)
- Smallville can be fun - late 17:48:27 05/30/02 (8)
- Smallville can be fun? - Ted in NJ 11:08:17 06/03/02 (2)
- You need to see several episodes; that was a rather poor example. - Audiophilander 09:28:30 06/04/02 (1)
- I'll try again. - Ted in NJ 13:13:52 06/04/02 (0)
- Still miss DS9 - padreken 18:27:14 05/30/02 (4)
- Re: Still miss DS9 - Bruce from DC 11:25:51 05/31/02 (2)
- Re: Still miss DS9 - padreken 11:59:41 05/31/02 (1)
- Re: I wouldn't know, Ken - Bruce from DC 15:23:24 05/31/02 (0)
- DS9 reruns - late 08:43:32 05/31/02 (0)