In Reply to: Lord of the Rings, after due contemplation.... posted by late on February 19, 2002 at 13:07:25:
... when the SE Lord of the Rings DVD comes out in November. There will be 30 or more minutes of fellowship footage reinserted that was edited out for time considerations in order to make the film an acceptable length for bottom-line conscious theater owners and producers. I'm sure that it will not placate your concerns entirely, but I think you ask the impossible of a film trying to create the atmosphere of such an epic story. [see linked URL]BTW, I don't think there can ever be a fair appraisal of LoTR when comparing the classic books and the soon-to-be-classic cinema versions of the epic because they each have qualities that the other can not share. That said, I think Peter Jackson has achieved the best meld of the two genres which is an amazing accomplishment unto itself. Just remember, so much could've been badly done or ruined, when instead nearly everything was done correctly.
Audiophilander
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- You may have to re-evaluate ... - AuPh 09:50:02 02/20/02 (1)
- Re: You may have to re-evaluate ... - Larry S 18:43:53 03/10/02 (0)