In Reply to: Mystic River posted by patrickU on June 28, 2004 at 14:31:34:
only considers the quality of Penn's performance.
When Ben Del Toro is also considered...
Naomi does a credible job, too, so far superior to Robbins' wife or the inexplicably cold LL (Sean's wife) (Robbins and Bacon I found much better than Penn's over the top effort).
I found the sense of dread in "21" was one of the most intense feelings I've ever felt in film, and it was sustained for a long period (the revenge piece felt added on and detracted).
That being said, the scene in which Penn races to the park and finally realizes its his daughter and begins to scream, "Is that my daughter in there?" is one of the most compelling in film history.
One last point: the two brothers in Mystic were terrible actors!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- No, 21 Grams was far superior, even if one - tinear 06:48:47 06/29/04 (9)
- I stopped 21G's at two-thirds. I was bored senseless. n - albee33 06:16:34 06/30/04 (0)
- Best acting in both movies was Tim Robbins. Worst acting was Kevin Bacon as the cop. (nt) - PdL 07:55:27 06/29/04 (2)
- Re: Laurence Fishburne did a good job. nt - patrickU 13:41:55 06/29/04 (1)
- Good point - I forgot about him. LF is pretty consistent. (nt) - PdL 13:52:21 06/29/04 (0)
- Re: Good performances don´t make a better film. - patrickU 06:55:32 06/29/04 (4)
- MR built to a climax....and it disappointed. Penn - tinear 18:00:15 06/29/04 (3)
- Re: MR built to a climax....and it disappointed. Penn - patrickU 01:00:32 06/30/04 (2)
- Penn is Sean, of course. Have you seen "Dead Man Walking"? - tinear 06:35:45 06/30/04 (1)
- Re: Yes I did... - patrickU 07:15:01 06/30/04 (0)