In Reply to: Top 20 films of all time......... posted by RC on July 6, 2004 at 20:20:21:
...and I mean really great films, on many counts, like "Wild Strawberries" (no Bergman in that list, while "The Seventh Seal", "Persona", ...); "The Dead" ("Prizzi´s Honor is fun, a good film..., but "The Dead" is a true monument); Murnau´s "Nosferatu" is better than Herzog´s; "One, Two, Three", or "Some like it Hot" are among the best humorous films, and "Sunset Boulevard", another masterpiece by Wilder, is at the top of films about the cinema; no Buñuel ("Viridiana", "Tristana"...); no Ford ("Stagecoach", "The Grapes of Wrath", "The Quiet Man", "The Searchers", "The Man who killed Liberty Valance"...); no Hitchcock ("Psycho", "Vertigo"...); No Chaplin ("The Great Dictator", "Modern Times", "The Gold Rush"...); no Griffith ("The Birth of a Nation", "Intolerance"...); no Browning ("Freaks" is pure poetry and tenderness, in an unusual disguise...); no Visconti ("Il Gatopardo", "Grupo di Famiglia in un Interno", "La Caduta degli Dei", "Rocco and his Brothers", "Death in Venice"...); no Fellini ("La Dolce Vita", "La Strada", "Roma", "Amarcord"...); no de Sica ("The Bycicle Thief", "Umberto D", "La Ciocciara"...); no Taviani ("Padre Padrone"); no Pasolini ("Accattone", "Mamma Roma", "The Gospel according to St Matthew", "Teorema"...); no Vigo ("L'Atalante"...); no Dreyer ("The Word", "Dies Irae", "The Passion of Joan of Arc"...); no Eisenstein ("Battleship Potemkin", "Ivan the Terrible", "Alexander Nevski", "October"...); no...The list would be too long. But most of these films are much better than most in that list you´ve posted, and many of them have had such a huge influence on the evolution of filmic language that they should never be forgotten.
Who made that list, and on what merits?
Regards
BF
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Strange list, that one: too many of the truly best, missing... - orejones 02:03:24 07/07/04 (15)
- Rublev? - Eldragon 06:39:48 07/07/04 (0)
- Re: NO..... - patrickU 03:23:17 07/07/04 (13)
- A second, "thank you" to Bernardo. Ok, you guys are making - tinear 03:55:55 07/07/04 (12)
- "The Dead", a truly wonderful film. - Auricle 05:28:42 07/07/04 (7)
- Re: A shame that the only DVD is in Spain! nt - patrickU 06:10:59 07/07/04 (6)
- Re: A second, to eternity.... - patrickU 04:19:33 07/07/04 (3)
- Well, you see, I thought it was a documentary 'bout a band...nt - tinear 04:50:04 07/07/04 (2)
- ROTFLMAO!! (nt) - grinagog 06:09:38 07/07/04 (1)
- Hey, do you sinagog, too? nt - tinear 12:12:12 07/07/04 (0)