In Reply to: More from the Giancarlo weekend posted by Victor Khomenko on April 26, 2000 at 11:09:02:
You should not be surprised at this, given the long-standing alliance between the European artistic community (and, to slightly lesser degree, the US community) and the communist left. The Spanish Civil War, in particular, has been romanticized at least since Earnest Hemingway wrote "For Whom the Bell Tolls." The problem is that facsim lost the contest, and its evils were laid bare long before the same fate befell European/Russian communism and its evils were laid bare. And, of course, the persistence of belief even in the face of contrary evidence is a well-documented human phenomenon.Other "propaganda" films that come to mind:
"z" by Costa-Gavras (1967) very entertaining
"JFK" by Oliver Stone; laughable to anyone who lived through the period and remembers the events depicted
"The Hurricane" a vicious, dishonest, racially inflammatory polemic that was too much even for Hollywood to swallow; too bad -- a wonderful performance by Denzel Washington wastedAs for who is worse, Nazis or Communists? One can't make a comparison. Unlike the Russian communists, the Nazis didn't have 70 years to play in the sandbox. You must admit that they certainly got off to a *promising* start with the "final solution."
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: More from the Giancarlo weekend - Bruce from DC 14:49:47 04/26/00 (7)
- Re: More from the Giancarlo weekend - Victor Khomenko 15:34:50 04/26/00 (6)
- Re: More from the Giancarlo weekend - edta 19:12:00 04/26/00 (3)
- Stalin, the cockrooch with big ambitions (longish) - Victor Khomenko 05:47:48 04/27/00 (0)
- Re: More from the Giancarlo weekend - Mart 22:59:44 04/26/00 (1)
- Re: More from the Giancarlo weekend -- Spain and the Nazis - Bruce from DC 08:19:28 04/27/00 (0)
- An old newspaper reporter's credo: Never let the facts stand in the way of a good story! <nt> - Bruce from DC 15:51:40 04/26/00 (1)
- I think I've read those articles in the N.Y.Times & D.C.Post <nt> - Mart 23:16:23 04/26/00 (0)