In Reply to: A clumsy dodge posted by Victor Khomenko on November 14, 2004 at 14:40:08:
Dodge? You wrote that the opening scene was among the most ineptly done in history. You wrote that the opening scene is a pure playing on emotions. You wrote that rest of the film is idiotic. Those statements contain only conclusions, no analysis. I supplied you with an opinion of a noted WWII historian that directly refutes your statements, and yet not nary a word either supporting your conclusions or disputing those of Ambrose. Dodge? You have failed to do anything but provide blanket statements unsupported by any intelligent analysis. Kaka? Where, pray tell, did you learn that descriptive word? Is that a word of art? What level of higher education did you pick up that little chestnut?You wrote that WWII was a mutual accomplishment. Well, I suspect that your version of history is about as accurate as your reviews.
If your opinion of this film was based on single shot performed by a sniper, then I suspect you probably do not enjoy films. Probably not music either. Well, the fact that there is no Oz does not prevent me from loving that film. Though, I suspect, even that film has too much sentimentality for you. You asked what your nationality has to do with your opinions? I do not think it a secret that people from different places, and from different backgrounds, receive the same stimuli differently. Russians have a reputation of viewing music and events from a view in which emotions are not an important factor. Having met and known several Russian people, my experience with them confirms this reputation.
Although they never used the word Kaka.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: A clumsy dodge - jamesgarvin 17:05:34 11/14/04 (5)
- "Russians have a reputation of viewing music and events from a view in which emotions are not an important factor." - sjb 19:09:09 11/14/04 (4)
- Re: "Russians have a reputation of viewing music and events from a view in which emotions are not an important factor." - jamesgarvin 14:02:24 11/15/04 (0)
- Re: "Russians have a reputation of viewing music and events from a view in which emotions are not an important factor." - Victor Khomenko 06:31:45 11/15/04 (1)
- Victor you just got bitch slapped and sent to bed without dinner. - YECH 16:52:16 11/15/04 (0)
- Re: "Russians have a reputation of viewing music and events from a view in which emotions are not an important factor." - patrickU 04:36:44 11/15/04 (0)