Re: It is silly to brand a director based on one work

Posted by jamesgarvin (A) on November 14, 2004 at 18:27:42

In Reply to: It is silly to brand a director based on one work posted by Victor Khomenko on November 14, 2004 at 18:06:28:

Victor, once again you demonstrate your arrogance. Saying you like or do not like something is expressing a view point. Saying that because you do not like something it is therefore not good, as a fact, is arrogant.

You also again demonstrate your ability to change the statement made to suit your retort. I do not think that Tinear (and he can certainly correct me) was arguing that the violence was a good thing, or a bad thing. Merely that the current violence is more reflective of the world that we live in than the films made many years ago. With better technology and better education, we now know of Stalin's atrocities, Pol Pot, etc. Their violence makes that of todays film makers pale by comparison. Our parents and grandparents did not know of that violence, and therefore films did not depict it.

The problem with Tinear trying to define "black", is that you have taken it upon yourself to define the term, and define what is or is not "good", or "artistic." Your world does not includes grays, or any other colors for that matter. Shame.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Tarantino's films are no more violent than many others... - tinear 17:47:35 11/14/04 (13)

Re: Tarantino's films are no more violent than many others... - Jack G 05:38:44 11/15/04 (1)

Re: Tarantino's films are no more violent than many others... - patrickU 06:05:12 11/15/04 (0)

Re: Tarantino's films are no more violent than many others... - patrickU 04:31:53 11/15/04 (0)

tin, garvin called you arrogant - Victor Khomenko 18:50:40 11/14/04 (2)

Natural Born Killers ends up being what it attempts to satire. - Tom §. 06:54:54 11/15/04 (1)

I think you are quite right - Victor Khomenko 06:59:06 11/15/04 (0)

It is silly to brand a director based on one work - Victor Khomenko 18:06:28 11/14/04 (6)

Fecundity doesn't define greatness: how many paintings did Vermeer create? - tinear 18:09:22 11/16/04 (0)

Re: Tarantino and diversity - Gee LP 20:35:34 11/14/04 (2)

You said it well - Victor Khomenko 04:53:12 11/15/04 (1)

Re: You said it well - patrickU 09:37:55 11/15/04 (0)

Re: It is silly to brand a director based on one work - jamesgarvin 18:27:42 11/14/04 (1)

To say what I said was arrogant is arrogant - Victor Khomenko 18:58:14 11/14/04 (0)

Follow Ups

Re: It is silly to brand a director based on one work - jamesgarvin 18:27:42 11/14/04 (1)

To say what I said was arrogant is arrogant - Victor Khomenko 18:58:14 11/14/04 (0)

You can not post to an archived thread.