The New Yorker and Wall Street Journal dismissed it too, so my question to you is: - clarkjohnsen

Films/DVD Asylum

Movies from comedy to drama to your favorite Hollyweird Star.

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - The Constant Gardener - RGA 12:02:52 09/02/05 (22)

The New Yorker and Wall Street Journal dismissed it too, so my question to you is: - clarkjohnsen 09:17:19 09/03/05 (8)

Re: Scenes that lasted more than 6 seconds? - Dave-A 21:26:49 09/08/05 (1)

All the unfavorable reviews commented on the MTV-style cutting, which I too detest. nt - clarkjohnsen 08:07:14 09/10/05 (0)

Well I'll take this critic for 2 points Alex... - RGA 10:25:41 09/03/05 (5)

Powerful film with depth, social relevence & realistic love story, YES; thrilling adventure, ummm, ...not so sure. - Audiophilander 12:57:05 09/07/05 (0)

Naturally you failed to answer my question. nt - clarkjohnsen 11:42:31 09/03/05 (2)

Yes... - RGA 16:52:18 09/03/05 (1)

Of course - RGA 16:54:05 09/03/05 (0)

How about the New York Times... - RGA 10:44:51 09/03/05 (0)

"A wild ride to nowhere" -- Boston Weekly Dig - clarkjohnsen 09:13:14 09/03/05 (7)

it begins with grief and proceeds with sadness toward horror...This is one of the year's best films..Roger Ebert NT - RGA 10:11:26 09/03/05 (6)

Roger Ebert! I rest my case. nt - clarkjohnsen 11:41:36 09/03/05 (0)

A masterwork of suspense, romance and political intrigue. USA today - RGA 10:12:56 09/03/05 (4)

The movie is smart, serious, and adult about something that matters. Lisa Schwarzbaum - RGA 10:14:23 09/03/05 (3)

film that grips us dramatically, intellectually and emotionally...Kenneth Turan - RGA 10:15:36 09/03/05 (2)

the movie's human material is masterfully manipulated...Village Voice - RGA 10:21:15 09/03/05 (0)

slick, fast-paced production with first-rate performances and an emotional punch you won't soon forget. New York Daily - RGA 10:18:38 09/03/05 (0)

"Gardener" settles for familiar ground -- Boston Globe - clarkjohnsen 09:11:37 09/03/05 (1)

And your point is what? - RGA 10:05:30 09/03/05 (0)

Brasil may have the best "one-two" punch in directors, at the moment. nt - tinear 05:06:23 09/03/05 (0)

This has received a *huge* range of reviews, from good critics too. nt - clarkjohnsen 13:12:46 09/02/05 (1)

Sorry for the messy review... - RGA 18:12:54 09/02/05 (0)

Follow Ups

The New Yorker and Wall Street Journal dismissed it too, so my question to you is: - clarkjohnsen 09:17:19 09/03/05 (8)

Re: Scenes that lasted more than 6 seconds? - Dave-A 21:26:49 09/08/05 (1)

All the unfavorable reviews commented on the MTV-style cutting, which I too detest. nt - clarkjohnsen 08:07:14 09/10/05 (0)

Well I'll take this critic for 2 points Alex... - RGA 10:25:41 09/03/05 (5)

Powerful film with depth, social relevence & realistic love story, YES; thrilling adventure, ummm, ...not so sure. - Audiophilander 12:57:05 09/07/05 (0)

Naturally you failed to answer my question. nt - clarkjohnsen 11:42:31 09/03/05 (2)

Yes... - RGA 16:52:18 09/03/05 (1)

Of course - RGA 16:54:05 09/03/05 (0)

How about the New York Times... - RGA 10:44:51 09/03/05 (0)