In Reply to: History of Violence: big deal? posted by TopPop on March 31, 2006 at 21:56:11:
Granted, "History ..." wasn't a *GREAT* movie and please don't ask me why a movie "earns" awards! ( Crash ? Crash? Crash? )But ...
I thought "History ..." had terrific performances by all. Standouts were William Hurt and Ed Harris playing their roles with relish and flair. Viggo Mortensen was perfectly cast as the shadowy character whose outside doesn't always match the inside. I loved the explosive fight scenes and the Freudian sex scenes were fun too.
Usually violent films don't appeal to me and despite the title, I didn't think this film was violent in a disturbing & jarring way.I know I'll ruffle some feathers here - but film makers like Tarrantino create a *false* suspense based on the threat of what they will show you- instead of "real" non-manipulative suspense based on character development and imagination. This kind of approach leaves me wanting to shower after puking my popcorn.
"History...." violence never got under my skin in an "icky" way and always seemed staged like an action comic .... AND - the acting was superb. The end result for me was a unique and entertaining film.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: History of Violence: big deal? - Jim Campilongo 04:43:41 04/01/06 (11)
- "Superb acting?" Your yardstick must be slanted towards - tinear 09:20:48 04/01/06 (10)
- You mean Viggo is bald(ing)??? - JoeKool 17:06:33 04/02/06 (0)
- Re: "Superb acting?" Your yardstick must be slanted towards - Analog Scott 15:59:07 04/01/06 (7)
- Re: "Superb acting?" Your yardstick must be slanted towards - PdL 07:47:40 04/02/06 (6)
- Maybe you didn't get the point... - Analog Scott 09:51:26 04/02/06 (5)
- Speaking of a meaningful answer - Maybe or probably? - PdL 04:34:08 04/03/06 (4)
- Dude, get a clue. - Analog Scott 20:48:27 04/03/06 (3)
- A well deserved reply - PdL 10:40:13 04/04/06 (2)
- Re: A well deserved reply - Analog Scott 15:08:39 04/04/06 (1)
- Re: A well deserved reply - PdL 17:20:53 04/04/06 (0)
- Have you been talking with Eddy H. and Billy? - Jim Campilongo 10:57:24 04/01/06 (0)