In Reply to: What name would you put as the greatest film director on your one name list? posted by patrickU on August 31, 2007 at 06:04:24:
The director of the film that is almost inevitably at the top of all those 'top one hundred films' lists must deserve mention as a possibility for 'greatest director'. It's difficult to recall shot set-ups and camera angles from any movie since to equal what Welles gave us in 'Citizen Kane'.
Living? I'm tempted to say Coen Brothers. The body of their work shows a willingness to branch out into unfamiliar (read: possibly unprofitable) genres, usually with excellent results. Their comedies are laugh-out-loud funny, without treating the audience like 3rd-grade hicks. They use metaphor and allegory even in their comedies (which can sometimes be over-the-top, but always gives their films a broader context). They've had films that didn't get the credit they deserve ('Hudsucker Proxy') and one total dog ('Lady Killers'), but there is no directing/writing team, ever since I was totally blown away by 'Blood Simple', whose latest movie I look more forward to than the Coens.
BTW, great question/post. Extremely tough to answer.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- What, no Orson Welles? - powermatic 14:40:04 08/31/07 (6)
- Magnificent Ambersons and A Touch of Evil also are convincing - tinear 16:01:58 09/01/07 (1)
- RE: Magnificent Ambersons and A Touch of Evil also are convincing - powermatic 16:42:51 09/01/07 (0)
- RE: If the Coen then.. - patrickU 05:26:37 09/01/07 (0)
- good call on the coens - musiclistener 15:04:02 08/31/07 (2)
- RE: Not be " chi chi " enough for this crowd... - patrickU 05:23:28 09/01/07 (0)
- I thought I heard some 'tut-tutting' as I was writing out the post, - powermatic 16:28:11 08/31/07 (0)