Maybe.I'm not a fan of "westerns" but this film transcends the genre by combing historical narration, flashbacks, character development, and Oscar performances from some of the cast.
Let's just say the actor in the Affleck family may not be Ben. Casey turned in a brilliantly nuanced performance as Robert Ford (the coward) while Pitt was stood out as the weakest link with his usual "non-nuanced" performance. All the characters were spot-on in what is seemingly an "actor's" movie filled with tight facial shots galore.
Although the film is nearly three hours it moves painlessly along until the undoing of the coward, Bob Ford.
The history of the James Gang was certainly interesting in the fact that most of it was made up to sell dime novels. Bob Ford, as a child, became tangled in the fantasy of being a James "ganger" but proved to strange and odd to ever make the grade. We also see an affable Jesse who loves his wife and kids but has no problem "dispatching" those he doesn't trust.
The film has an "artsy" atmosphere and does (IMO) for westerns what The Thin Red Line did for war movies.
Must see.
.
Complicit Constapo Talibangelical since MMIII
Edits: 10/29/07
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - The Assassination of Jesse James: Best Picture of the Year? - mr grits 18:33:59 10/28/07 (15)
- The Thin Red Line had the worst miscast of modern film. - tinear 06:21:20 10/29/07 (14)
- RE: The Thin Red Line had the worst miscast of modern film. - rico 05:03:14 10/30/07 (0)
- "Apocalypse Now"...IMO is a highly over-rated narcissistic film.... - TWB 14:50:06 10/29/07 (5)
- RE: "Apocalypse Now"...IMO is a highly over-rated narcissistic film.... - rico 05:06:28 10/30/07 (0)
- Try "Apocalypse Now Redux"?... - mpathus 21:19:39 10/29/07 (3)
- Disagree. The Playmates acting was so bad it killed those scenes. * - mr grits 06:32:11 10/30/07 (1)
- RE: Disagree. The Playmates acting was so bad it killed those scenes. * - mpathus 19:11:44 11/12/07 (0)
- Disagree. Redux is bloated and a perfect example of why - tinear 04:18:07 10/30/07 (0)
- RE: The Thin Red Line had the worst miscast of modern film. - Rod H. 12:33:52 10/29/07 (0)
- Travolta played a stereotype......had you been in the military it would have meant more. * - mr grits 07:12:57 10/29/07 (5)
- RE: Travolta played a stereotype......had you been in the military it would have meant more. * - Peter H-son 13:51:15 10/29/07 (0)
- I attended a military school, an admiral's kid was my - tinear 09:48:14 10/29/07 (3)
- He represented a "young turk" who pushed his way into Gen Staff, whereas..... - mr grits 13:20:57 10/29/07 (0)
- So, having encountered a couple of general officers... - EBerlin 10:53:37 10/29/07 (1)
- Don't be so skittish, you're not - tinear 14:52:11 10/29/07 (0)