In Reply to: American Gangster: New American Classic.... posted by mr grits on November 2, 2007 at 17:57:06:
Hardly any tension in any scene: you've seen it all before, anyway.
Denzel gives a spectacular performance in a wasted cause. Denby, in The New Yorker, pans the film because of its lack of a moral viewpoint which he finds a key component of Goodfellas and Godfather II. I don't particularly care if monsters are glorified if the film itself has other strong qualities: this one doesn't.
Crowe has many scenes, many in which you'd expect to get some fireworks but... nothing.
Forget this and rent your favorite old favorite. Heat, for one, shows a master criminal in a much better film.
I was kind of shocked at the lack of drama in this film, it certainly doesn't look like the same guy's work who made Blade Runner.
SPOILER:
The evil cop, who did enough stuff to Denzel to make one wish for some kind of showdown, removes himself in what must be the most disappointing resolution in modern crime film. If you're going to paint the guy as Satan, let his fall be worthwhile.
Remember Popeye and the French Connection films?
Now that was a convincing cop.
Crowe looked like he had so very much appreciated the mousy depiction which Matt Damon gave of a CIA agent in The Good Shepherd that he followed that boring example.
What a waste of two good actors...
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Another opinion: very disappointing. - tinear 05:28:04 11/03/07 (15)
- RE: Sorry Tin, I'm with Grits on this one. - Dave-A 12:11:36 11/06/07 (8)
- It could have been done better....(no excuse)...:-) - Audio Pharaoh 18:59:12 11/06/07 (0)
- Truth or fiction live by the same rules: boring is boring. - tinear 15:37:52 11/06/07 (6)
- RE: Truth or fiction live... - Dave-A 06:47:42 11/09/07 (0)
- True enough, but... - jamesgarvin 09:53:39 11/07/07 (4)
- I especially like when someone assumes a poster is such and such and then - tinear 04:53:41 11/08/07 (3)
- Such and Such? - jamesgarvin 07:44:27 11/08/07 (2)
- Jesus, do you read what you post? - tinear 15:28:37 11/10/07 (1)
- RE: Jesus, do you read what you post? - jamesgarvin 10:41:59 11/13/07 (0)
- Totally agree with you Tinear.....Now, if it was Denzel - Audio Pharaoh 21:27:18 11/05/07 (0)
- took far too long for Denzel and Crowe to have a scene and - Duilawyer 10:26:38 11/04/07 (0)
- It was based on a true story..... - mr grits 08:10:57 11/03/07 (3)
- no fighting - Duilawyer 11:09:58 11/04/07 (0)
- I do not believe Crowe's character could have been both investigating officer and prosectuor. - Duilawyer 10:29:14 11/04/07 (0)
- Yes, a true story but, as the promos say, parts are fictionalized. Doesn't matter, - tinear 15:01:42 11/03/07 (0)