In Reply to: U-571 posted by R. Hertz on March 14, 2001 at 10:16:08:
Don't read this if you intend to see it.This movie had a serious flaw for me.
If the US needed the Nazi code encryption machine so badly to decode German radio transmissions, how did they get the location message from the disabled German sub decoded? The whole movie collapses for me there.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: U-571 <spoiler!> - Troy 13:28:08 03/15/01 (4)
- Troy, the U-571 has nothing to do with the historical facts n/t - Romy 14:30:11 03/15/01 (3)
- It's not about historic fact, it's about failed logic! - Troy 11:33:36 03/16/01 (0)
- think that's why the number doesn't even match - Mart 15:27:09 03/15/01 (1)
- Re: think that's why the number doesn't even match - Romy 16:36:16 03/15/01 (0)