In Reply to: "Synechdoche, New York," you'll love this film if listening posted by tinear on November 30, 2008 at 17:58:28:
...I'm guessing you either missed stuff or you just don't like this *kind* of film. Given the degree of self-awareness and intelligence that prevails in Kaufmann's work I would seriously doubt that "We're all going to die--- yet, we still have to go on living" would have been written without irony. That is, he probably intended it as a line people would recognize as a cliche and intended an additional dimension of meaning. For example, he could have intended it as a comment on the superficiality of the character who said it. When I see the film I may have a clearer idea about this!
One can't take everything said by a character in a film to be something that the author is stating positively or "agrees" with.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Given the published reviews I've read... - EBerlin 20:47:07 12/01/08 (12)
- Yup. That was spot on. - sjb 02:31:57 12/02/08 (5)
- I want to be clear... - EBerlin 05:52:56 12/02/08 (4)
- RE: I want to be clear... - sjb 08:35:11 12/02/08 (0)
- He never agrees with me :-( nt - tinear 07:46:13 12/02/08 (2)
- That's not true. - sjb 08:36:31 12/02/08 (1)
- LOL! nt - tinear 10:50:25 12/02/08 (0)
- EB, you're quite wrong and need to see the film. It's one long--- - tinear 21:18:58 12/01/08 (5)
- Well, I will see it (hopefully soon)... - EBerlin 21:25:34 12/01/08 (4)
- Kaufman didn't direct the films you mentioned. I very much liked - tinear 07:47:52 12/02/08 (3)
- I am aware that Synecdoche is his first directing effort... - EBerlin 07:55:30 12/02/08 (2)
- He was deeply involved in the process of Malkovich and Adaptation all the way through. - sjb 08:43:49 12/02/08 (1)
- The very worst moment came somewhere SPOILER - tinear 19:57:20 12/02/08 (0)