In Reply to: How could it offer answers and be "real"? posted by sjb on January 26, 2009 at 20:01:01:
conjecture about her, in her most important motivations.
Clearly, the director made one critical fault: he didn't portray, in a visual medium, the pivotal scene, i.e. the barn burning. Kind of like if "Valkyrie" left out the bunker actual blasting. Allowing Winslet to show us her feelings, would have made us understand and care for her a tad more, perhaps. I know, I know, leaving it vague allows us to imagine it. But that's a cop out.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- You bring up a very good point. You are left to - tinear 07:43:07 01/29/09 (0)