In Reply to: I heard a wag say posted by danj on July 22, 2009 at 14:09:20:
chops JD did.
McQ had ZERO range, a complete inability to portray personal suffering, or emotional nuance.
He also wasn't at his best with dialogue over a sentence.
Dean was the complete package, even at a young age. He could explode from hurt to white-hot anger in an instant and then reverse to vulnerability.
McQ was a heroic actor in the old sense.
I think his most effective work occurred in those films wherein the character was cool in the face of great danger; his physical presence and grace also were of star quality.
Unfortunately, I think his weakest roles were in more demanding roles such as "Papillon"( a very disappointing and flawed film, anyhow) and the equally bad "The Sand Pebbles."
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- McQ, I'd argue, didn't have anywhere near the acting - tinear 15:59:47 07/22/09 (9)
- Just curious, and not to question... - mpathus 22:31:48 07/23/09 (1)
- I think the films are so fatally flawed NO one could have saved them. nt - tinear 10:46:47 07/24/09 (0)
- I never said I agreed with the wag but - danj 09:49:29 07/23/09 (0)
- I dug up a couple of additional things about McQ. - free.ranger 18:19:50 07/22/09 (5)
- RE: I dug up a couple of additional things about McQ. - danj 22:51:59 07/23/09 (0)
- Whaaa? - powermatic 07:52:59 07/23/09 (2)
- Or "Cat On A Hot Tin Roof" or "The Hustler" or - danj 09:25:56 07/23/09 (1)
- "Hombre" is, perhaps, his most undeservedly underrated film. Richard Boone's performance is - tinear 15:27:33 07/24/09 (0)
- He was in a adolescent correctional facility for several years and always - tinear 19:09:14 07/22/09 (0)