In Reply to: Is "Dr. Strangelove" Kubrick's masterpiece?? posted by Mike K on August 22, 2009 at 13:50:44:
One of them is sense of proportion and knowing where to stop. Kubrick lost there on these counts. The out of control arm scene is so ridiculously primitive, it is capable of single handedly destroying any claim at greatness. Masters just don't make such mistakes. Throughout his career Kubrick remained the master of scenes, but not of films. His early works might be the exception to that rule.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Masterpiece is too big a word, it presumes too many things - Victor Khomenko 19:14:45 08/26/09 (8)
- A satire -- as "Dr. Strangelove" is -- is the artistic equivalent of "reductio ad absurdum" in Logic... - orejones 03:56:03 08/29/09 (1)
- RE: OH Boy! Yes it is a satire and you are the satyr of politic. - patrickU 06:03:15 08/30/09 (0)
- Shakespeare had to throw a few lines to the cheap seats - late 05:58:36 08/27/09 (5)
- In fifty years no one will know what the film is about - Victor Khomenko 06:32:42 08/27/09 (4)
- It's already 45 years old * - Mike K 09:36:52 08/27/09 (3)
- late is about twice as old nt - Victor Khomenko 09:44:55 08/27/09 (2)
- I am sure we will all forget about it in 5 years time... nt - late 05:51:11 08/30/09 (1)
- That's fifty years from now, buddy - Victor Khomenko 06:25:09 08/30/09 (0)