In Reply to: I actually thought he was perfectly cast. posted by Harmonia on November 11, 2009 at 11:48:01:
has little or no sense of humor regarding his religion, according to his prior thread post. That's okay. But, having been raised a Catholic, I have no problem laughing at my "old" religion, or any other.
Actually, generations of Jewish comedians have found their faith a fertile source of mirth, from Mel Brooks through Woody Allen.
Would NO Jewish boy get stoned and attend his ceremony? I don't know, that's an awfully large assertion by JI. Cannot Rabbis be a rich source of humor, too? How about attorneys and doctors? Fact is, the Coen's lampooned pretty much everyone in this film, including the WASP neighbors, the Jewish Princess/Queen neighbor's wife (gosh, I wonder if ANY Jewish middle-aged wives smoked pot in those days?).
This was a hysterically funny film: the theater was rocking during many scenes. Like I mentioned, when it ended, there was a general wave of disappointment which flowed through the crowd: it wanted a lot more and so did I!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Agreement: a perfect lead casting. It's hard to maintain the nuances he did in such broad satire. I think JI - tinear 15:44:53 11/11/09 (6)
- "when it ended, there was a general wave of disappointment"--yeah, tell me about it - Jazz Inmate 22:22:11 11/11/09 (5)
- Now wait just a gol darned minute... - Harmonia 17:02:33 11/12/09 (1)
- RE: Now wait just a gol darned minute... - Jazz Inmate 15:53:14 11/13/09 (0)
- Rottentomatoes.com has it at 85%, a damned fine showing for a cult director's black comedy. - tinear 08:04:58 11/12/09 (2)
- Barton Fink was a black comedy. Serious Man was crap - Jazz Inmate 08:23:41 11/12/09 (1)
- OK...we get it. - Harmonia 16:48:19 11/12/09 (0)