Films/DVD Asylum

RE: HAL

98.26.64.13

This Post Has Been Edited by the Author

In Reply to: RE: Fresh Musings on Kubrick’s Monument for the Ages: 2001 posted by mpathus on May 10, 2008 at 23:20:11

That's a very interesting point you make about HAL and the Jupiter mission being a kind of "survival of the fittest" microcosm, one I never reflected on before.

The HAL 9000 may be, and I am certainly original in suggesting this, one of the great characters of cinematic history; and quite unfairly, Kubrick was never given much credit for creating characters.

HAL is wonderful to psychoanalyze. After his psychopathic, murderous rampage, as he is being electronically lobotomized by Dave, he recalls his early childhood. His intructor, Mr. Langley, taught him a song, which he offers to sing for a group of observers. Everyone knows the song is "Daisy", or as I knew it, "A bicycle built for two."

This childlike, innocent recollection seems far removed from the egotistic murder spree we have just witnessed -- until one realizes that the song itself is a very strange one to have taught a sentient being who has no ability to exist in the physical world, who will never ride a bicycle, who will never participate in the carnal pleasures and emotional intimacies that we physical humans take for granted. When this aspect of HAL's existence are considered, Mr. Langley choice of tutorial material is not only inappropriate, it is downright cruel. He's screwing with HAL's head, in effect. For this reason, HAL's psychopathic veer can be explained easily: He was a victim of child abuse.

Clarke, who collaborated with Kubrick on the script, later said that Stanley Kubrick was the most intelligent man he'd ever met. Mr. Clarke had met quite a few intelligent men, was was pre-eminently one himself.

Follow Ups: