In Reply to: M. Night is awful posted by barryb on July 3, 2010 at 09:48:39:
The "twist" that water was deadly to the aliens was completely idiotic. Our atmosphere has lots of water vapor in it. It's called humidity. If water really was toxic to the aliens then leaving their vehicles without protective suits would have been equivalent to a naked human stepping into the sulphuric acid clouds on Venus.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Signs was so stupid that it was insulting - Rob Doorack 07:55:50 07/08/10 (9)
- don't think they were going for "realistic... - Grant 07:20:14 07/12/10 (0)
- Agree completely, almost - barryb 09:04:59 07/11/10 (4)
- "a sad joke"? - Rob Doorack 19:45:49 07/11/10 (1)
- Venus - barryb 07:16:12 07/12/10 (0)
- "there hasn't been a realistic depiction of the aliens since Close Encounters?" - volunteer 17:25:04 07/11/10 (1)
- Thousands of eye witnesses and common sense - barryb 07:20:58 07/12/10 (0)
- what kind of technological development. . . - Larry I 09:25:02 07/09/10 (2)
- Another depiction of aliens as scary - barryb 09:09:47 07/11/10 (1)
- "until they took out all mentions of the words "Area 51". " - volunteer 18:59:18 07/15/10 (0)