In Reply to: Much thought went into "Star Wars." It's still dreck. And a guy writing a PHd hardly posted by tinear on March 18, 2011 at 12:43:18:
Star wars was a typical tale of empires and rebels. There was no symbolism you could sink your teeth into, and the producer admitted he ripped off the plot from Kurosawa.
Alien was more original at least regarding the points I made previously about imagery and symbolism. Even the gimmicks used to generate suspense were thoughtful. When you expect to see an enormous reptillian monster, you see a soft furry cat. The way the film throws these constant mindblowing curveballs at the audience is fairly brilliant. I won't say ingenius because it falls short of a masterpiece but not by a whole lot.
If it wasn't your cup of tea, so be it. By the way, the PhD candidate was a "she" not a "he" which is not surprising. The hero of Alien turns out to be...a woman. Which appealed to a lot of feminists at the time. You could throw a dart blindfolded and hit a feminist at UCSC...at least in the days I went there.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- The thought that went into Star Wars stayed on the surface - Jazz Inmate 17:09:55 03/18/11 (0)