Since we're having a "best scifi" thread below, let's have a best
westerns thread.
I don't know whether these are the best, but they are my favorites of
the ones I've seen (forewarned: I'm a Peckinpah fan).
The Wild Bunch
Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid
The Ballad of Cable Hogue
The Proposition (this is an aussie flick, still qualifies imho)
The Good The Bad The Ugly (best Eastwood flick ever)
Silverado (this film has flashes of brilliance and true banality, but
overall it's a good one).
Once Upon a Time in the West (too clean and neat, but some great
individual scenes and the proper moral ambiguity).
One of my overarching criteria for a good western is that it have a
gritty, grubby, nasty, dirty, morally ambiguous feeling to it. The
characters cannot be clean, wear clean clothes constantly, and look like
they just had fresh makeup applied; the towns need to look like they
were made from cheap lumber and thrown together quickly (which they
were); the script needs to depict the moral qualities of the era, which
were not pretty at best. Peckinpah excels at this sort of thing.
I do not like John Wayne or Clint Eastwood, as neither of them can act
and they always play the same character from film to film.
Lack of skill dictates economy of style. - Joey Ramone
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - The best westerns of all time - Mike K 09:45:04 03/20/11 (42)
- Once Upon a Time in the West, Dead Man n/t - Vinylized 13:49:50 03/24/11 (1)
- Dead Man! - Enophile 13:18:29 03/31/11 (0)
- Add in "Lonely Are the Brave"...N/T - musetap 12:27:19 03/24/11 (0)
- The MisFits ( slaps forehead ) - grinagog 00:56:59 03/24/11 (0)
- I love westerns... - Harmonia 01:01:46 03/22/11 (2)
- Another Silverado fan, here. - Enophile 13:19:36 03/31/11 (0)
- The Claim.........Yes! - afilado 10:11:41 03/22/11 (0)
- Little Big Man (1970), There Will Be Blood (2007)... - mpathus 15:46:33 03/21/11 (1)
- Little Big Man was really terrific. - Enophile 13:16:34 03/31/11 (0)
- Agreement on ....... - afilado 11:08:43 03/21/11 (3)
- Like your agreement and would add Lonesome Dove - Daryl Zero 16:39:56 03/21/11 (1)
- Yes.. - afilado 17:22:19 03/21/11 (0)
- You beat me to it ... - reelsmith. 13:23:28 03/21/11 (0)
- RE: The best westerns of all time - padreken 10:41:57 03/21/11 (0)
- THE SEARCHERS and ONE EYED JACKS - grhughes 10:00:04 03/21/11 (0)
- Rustler's Rhapsody ..nt - late 09:25:29 03/21/11 (0)
- RE: John Ford. nt - patrickU 09:20:30 03/21/11 (0)
- Blazing Saddles...nt - dwill123 05:43:55 03/21/11 (0)
- Lemonade Joe - Victor Khomenko 05:29:19 03/21/11 (0)
- RE: The best westerns of all time - grinagog 00:54:51 03/21/11 (0)
- What about Unforgiven? - Jazz Inmate 23:08:17 03/20/11 (1)
- It's weird, but I have a hard time... - Harmonia 01:46:53 03/22/11 (0)
- I DO like John Wayne and Clint Eastwood. - Dalton 17:18:31 03/20/11 (1)
- Stagecoach is entertaining, I can see why people liked the Duke back then - PhilJ 22:51:28 03/20/11 (0)
- The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford * - mr grits 15:55:32 03/20/11 (5)
- This makes a great double bill with Ang Lee's Ride With The Devil - Harmonia 12:34:57 03/23/11 (0)
- brilliant movie - mbnx01 11:15:37 03/22/11 (0)
- RE:Yup ... - Jeff Starrs 11:04:43 03/21/11 (0)
- That's the one I that tops my list - DFaulds 08:43:19 03/21/11 (0)
- Absolutely! - Prisoners 16:59:06 03/20/11 (0)
- Wyatt Earp - mbnx01 15:14:37 03/20/11 (3)
- I like the original better...'My Darling Clementine' - Tony D. 16:27:59 03/20/11 (1)
- Me too! - Harmonia 01:54:54 03/22/11 (0)
- THATS the one I couldn’t remember. * - MMasztal 15:31:56 03/20/11 (0)
- RE: grity, ugly almost like Bruegel painting: McCabe & Mrs. Miller - Eldragon@gmx.com 15:05:33 03/20/11 (0)
- Howz about combining the two genres - Westworld anyone?... - musetap 14:14:27 03/20/11 (1)
- I bet you can't wait for Cowboys & Aliens. - Harmonia 23:45:40 03/21/11 (0)
- Open Range... Jeremiah Johnson... - MMasztal 13:51:46 03/20/11 (0)
- 'Shane' * - Tony D. 12:02:54 03/20/11 (1)
- Shane is one of the best films in any genre. nt - Dave Mester 12:48:32 03/21/11 (0)
- "Lust in the Dust". nt - geoff 11:32:27 03/20/11 (0)
- RE: The best westerns of all time - Rod H. 10:42:53 03/20/11 (0)