In Reply to: Please (seriously) excuse for me for disagreeing, but i hate 'Wonderful Life' -nt- posted by late on December 7, 2001 at 07:03:05:
I believe you misconstrued JAD's statement when you disagreed. There
should be no disagreement as he said that his FAVORITE film was
"It's A Wonderful Life",it seems to me that this was based more on subjective considerations
than any overwhelming objective criteria. I
also don't particularly care for "IAWL", but I wouldn't consider it
proper to disagree with him or anyone else about their
favorite film. I might, however, take issue with someone who proclaimed a certain film as "Best" or "Greatest" and ask for some
kind of objective justification. - AH
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Please (seriously) excuse for me for disagreeing, but i hate 'Wonderful Life' -nt- - AudioHead 11:08:50 12/07/01 (4)
- Re: Please (seriously) excuse for me for disagreeing, but i hate 'Wonderful Life' -nt- - JAD 06:27:48 12/10/01 (3)
- Controversial.... - AudioHead 09:46:02 12/10/01 (2)
- We'll, I've disagreed with some rankings, ... - Audiophilander 09:40:20 12/13/01 (1)
- I Agree That The AFI List Is OK Overall, But..... - AudioHead 12:19:54 12/14/01 (0)