In Reply to: The top Academy Award nominated films... posted by mkuller on February 26, 2013 at 20:41:40:
None of the American entries, anyhow.
Good drama, yes, but would you say "Argo" or "Zero" or "Les Mis" had much more to say than their straightforward stories?
Once Upon a Time in Anatolia.
Amour.
A Separation.
Elena.
These are films that rise to artistry, that do so while addressing timeless issues and that hold uncompromising mirrors up to their subjects and their times.
Yes, Hollywood at one time knew how to do this, though of course it was always only a small percentage of its output--- which is reasonable to expect.
And a KEY point was the sequel/prequel part: original ideas, original scriptwriting has DISAPPEARED.
Edits: 02/27/13
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- "really good?" Is that the bar? Not a one rose above the entertainment category. - tinear 09:42:55 02/27/13 (4)
- Never expect art from film. * - mr grits 15:52:05 02/27/13 (3)
- Well you certainly can't with most of the crap you prefer. That said, - tinear 07:56:05 02/28/13 (2)
- Art is more than dark shadows and minimal dialog . . . - mr grits 10:05:37 03/01/13 (1)
- Tell it to Eisenstein. Tarkovsky. nt - tinear 20:38:44 03/01/13 (0)