Well I guess if the midrange & top are similar quality on both I'd go for the floorstander and have done that here.However many mini monitors have superior sound to floor standers so it is a bit dangerous to generalise. Also the room acoustics is a factor to consider if you have bass pouring out from both ends of the room. It could prove to be superb but, given the wrong combination of room dimensions it could end up very wierd.
Much as I'd like to give more specific advise it is really impossible. In your situation I would try to borrow a pair of floorstanders from a dealer or friend and try them out and then make the decision. Even then, a deal of experimenting with positioning would be important before making that final decision.
John
Peace at AA
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
You can not post to an archived thread.