Home Video Asylum

TVs, VCRs, DVD players, Home Theater systems and more.

Re: exactly why I installed my...

I swore I would move to either DirecTV or Dish satellite service by now but decided to give Comcast digital cable another try.

I've been on analog cable forever and tried digital cable with a HD set top box about a year ago. I was completely unimpressed. At that time there were only a couple HD channels broadcast via Comcast cable in my area plus the clunker Motorola set top box was very slow to navigate or channel hop and the regular (non-premium) channels looked worse than analog cable. Back then, about a year ago, I picked up more HD channels using my Samsung HD tuner and an outdoor UHF antenna than via Comcast cable.

Here it is about a year later..., all local network channels available in HD over cable plus ESPN HD, Discovery HD, a couple PBS channels in HD, premium channels in HD, and a couple "INHD" channels. See http://inhd.com INHD and INHD2 are part of the HD package and not additional cost channels.

The latest Motorola High Definition DVR set top box is far better and faster to navigate and channel hop than the previous model. It can record HD or standard definition programs which can be scheduled from the onscreen Program Guide or recorded instantly by pressing the record button. It will actually record two different programs at the same time if you wish. And of course there's the instant replay feature. The regular channels look much better than they did with the older Motorola box and it's awesome recording High-Def 'widescreen' material with 5.1 Dolby Digital sound. PBS, INHD, and some of the other channels broadcast concerts in HD and with the 5.1 Dolby Digital sound through the home theater setup, it's outstanding.

I have two of the new Motorola Hi-Def DVR's in my home but I'm about to try a CableCard which will allow my new LCD flat-screen TV to pickup digital cable including HD content w/o the external Motorola box. The plus side is a real clean look with the LCD TV mounted to the wall with no additional gear nearby to clutter things up. The down side is that the CableCard is not bi-directional in that it does not accept ONDEMAND or Pay-Per-View requests and of course it doesn't have a DVR.... which is OK for this particular bedroom LCD TV. They're working on bi-directional CableCards now and we might see them sometime in 2006.

So far I'm real happy with my setup. There was no expensive gear to buy. The Motorola HD DVR is a simple self-install project but I'm told that the CableCard requires a tech to come out and install it. I'm not sure why because you just plug it into the CableCard slot in TV.

Some other benefits include no lost signal due to rain or snow. It's been extremely reliable. Cable is however more expensive on a monthly basis (I think) but the flip side is there's no expensive gear to buy and no contracts to sign. I can cancel the whole thing at anytime w/o notice & w/o penalty.


This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
  Sonic Craft  


Follow Ups Full Thread
Follow Ups
  • Re: exactly why I installed my... - AbeCollins 18:32:09 12/27/05 (0)


You can not post to an archived thread.