In Reply to: Why are your ONLY posts bashing HD DVD and promoting blu-ray? posted by townsend on November 29, 2007 at 17:11:42:
the only controversy is how thes "advantages" translate to the real world. blu-ray has 50-60% advantage in both audio/video bitrate capacity (48 vs. 30 mbs) and storage capacity (50G vs. 30G) which can effect PQ/SQ quality but plenty of folks (probably mainly those with vested interests in HD-DVD) question whether the spec advantages translate into "practical" advantages.
OTOH, Toshiba's apparent marketing strategy means minimal (zero or less than zero) profit margins for retailer/manufacturer's trying to sell HD DVD. The BDA is apparently trying to maintain (obscene?) profit margins for the sales of Blu-ray and HD DVD is messing that up. I've the suspicion "Old Lund Christensen" may have an 'interest" in the winner of this format war. But then again, I also have an interest; I want the best possible PQ/SQ for all my movies and I believe Blu-ray does a better job of delivering it than HD DVD.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Blu-ray has "important" (?) advantages relevant to picture/sound quality.... - oscar 19:04:38 11/29/07 (19)
- RE: Blu-ray has "important" (?) advantages relevant to picture/sound quality.... - Jwm 13:34:08 11/30/07 (2)
- Your nephew has probably been overexposed to the early Sony 25G Blu-ray releases... - oscar 20:51:57 11/30/07 (1)
- Its very title dependent - Jack G 07:34:11 12/01/07 (0)
- "...blu-ray has 50-60% advantage in both audio/video bitrate capacity..." - But Oscar, ... - Audiophilander 22:33:45 11/29/07 (15)
- RE: "...blu-ray has 50-60% advantage in both audio/video bitrate capacity..." - But Oscar, ... - Duilawyer 22:19:34 12/01/07 (0)
- We can agree to disagree. - oscar 05:19:19 11/30/07 (13)
- "Have you had the chance to play around with lossless/uncompressed audio yet?" - Nope, but ... - Audiophilander 11:47:06 11/30/07 (12)
- The region blocking is useful to allow staggered releases of movies in theaters worldwide. - oscar 15:08:57 11/30/07 (11)
- "The region blocking is useful..." - Not to the customer. - Audiophilander 16:46:09 11/30/07 (10)
- Give it up , Auph - racerguy 18:38:58 11/30/07 (9)
- So Oldboy and Infernal Affairs are Hollywood blockbusters? - Jazz Inmate 18:47:55 11/30/07 (8)
- I see your reading comprehension problem hasn't improved - I'm sorry for you (nt) - racerguy 20:50:24 11/30/07 (7)
- I see you have no respect for copyright laws or intellectual property. Good luck with that NT - Jazz Inmate 22:41:03 11/30/07 (6)
- Wrong again, Jazz. You have my pity (nt) - racerguy 10:45:49 12/01/07 (4)
- Evidently, you've never read your own posts - Jazz Inmate 13:13:49 12/01/07 (3)
- I keep thinking you can't get any dumber, but you always prove me wrong. Oh well (nt) - racerguy 13:23:35 12/01/07 (2)
- you've given no indication that you're capable of thinking NT - Jazz Inmate 13:46:57 12/01/07 (1)
- How can you tell? :-) nt - racerguy 13:51:54 12/01/07 (0)
- Ummm, no offense, but why would you be concerned... - Audiophilander 00:50:30 12/01/07 (0)