In Reply to: Blu-Ray, letter boxing and zoom posted by jimmyjames on November 24, 2008 at 11:55:40:
Jimmy,
I am not sure I get why you bought a Blu-Ray player to begin with.
One reason, after all, is the picture quality, and integral to that is a disc where the film is mastered and shown in its correct aspect ratio.
You want to achieve two things at once, if I understand you correctly:
1.You want to ruin the original composition of the film you are viewing by chopping the sides off the wide-screen images to "fill" the screen.
2.You want to compromise the inherent extra resolution of a Blu-Ray disc by artificially zooming it in.
Again, why didn't you just stick with your regular, zoomable DVD player, where you could 'compensate for the retardation' to your heart's delight?
Speaking of which, I wish you would have had a chance to convey your feelings to the likes of Sergio Leone, Francis Ford Coppola or David Lean regarding their self-indulgence in choosing a wide frame for their films. It would have been a lively discussion.
CC.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Blu-Ray, letter boxing and zoom - Cosmic Closet 17:28:02 11/24/08 (12)
- RE: Blu-Ray, letter boxing and zoom - jimmyjames 06:54:08 11/25/08 (10)
- Perhaps you can just relegate your BD player to true 16x9 material - Russell Low 08:30:48 11/25/08 (2)
- I forgot to add that BDs of TV series are also 16x9... - Russell 08:31:58 11/26/08 (1)
- RE: I forgot to add that BDs of TV series are also 16x9... - Gmood1 11:22:07 11/26/08 (0)
- RE: Blu-Ray, letter boxing and zoom - Gmood1 08:28:08 11/25/08 (0)
- RE: Blu-Ray, letter boxing and zoom - Hornlover 08:03:46 11/25/08 (5)
- HOW DARE YOU! - GTF 20:02:07 11/30/08 (2)
- RE: HOW DARE YOU! - Hornlover 08:07:25 12/01/08 (1)
- RE: HOW DARE YOU! - GTF 13:08:35 12/01/08 (0)
- I'm amazed - jimmyjames 06:58:15 11/26/08 (1)
- RE: I'm amazed - Hornlover 07:35:51 11/26/08 (0)
- well said - Joe Murphy Jr 21:41:09 11/24/08 (0)