In Reply to: Not at all posted by Jazz Inmate on December 28, 2009 at 19:48:24:
This isn't the Outside or Film Asylum; your critical opinion of Avatar is based on political bias not on the quality of the film as a work of art as presented in 3D.>>> "Seems kind of nuts to buy new video gear on the slim chance that the few 3-D movies that warrant repeat viewing would be produced on 3-D blu-ray. Even if five good movies a year were released on 3-D it still wouldn't be worth it." <<<
There have already been quite a few interesting films projected in 3D (most were quite good and even the worst was more impressive in 3D). Trust me, more 3D films are on the way and it promises to be a cutting edge HT experience. Ironically, even the SONY PS3 will be upgradeable to 3D codec so I suspect you'll be changing your tune pretty quick (see link below).
Also, 3D capable televisions & projectors aren't intended simply as display devices for 3D films, they're just enhanced for it. Personally, I can't think of a better way to increase viewing pleasure (personal and for groups of friends) than the addition of the new 3D process to one's home theater.
Now admittedly, the new 3D processed films probably won't look great over an old Admiral CRT interlaced TV, but for those of us who are into expanding our HT capabilities to enhance the home cinema experience, well, that's another story!
Oh, FTR, having checked out a 60" JVC direct view 3D television being demo'd last summer at Siggraph I can convey here that it's just as impressive at handling 3D as front projected DLP in the IMAX theater, albeit on a smaller scale!
Of course, those diagnosed with permanent tunnel-vision may be precluded from fully enjoying 3D, but it might not be an obstacle for some of us here. ;O)
Cheers,
AuPh
Edits: 12/29/09
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- "Avatar is not something I'd ever buy." - Well, maybe it's something others will buy; did you ever consider that? - Audiophilander 00:33:50 12/29/09 (17)
- You'd buy it and I wouldn't - Jazz Inmate 22:36:21 12/29/09 (6)
- "...you bought several HD DVD players..." - I got mine for next to nothing with free disc offers & discounts; also, ... - Audiophilander 02:26:31 12/30/09 (5)
- RE: "...you bought several HD DVD players..." - I got mine for next to nothing with free disc offers & discounts; also, - Jazz Inmate 10:00:51 12/30/09 (4)
- Lets try this one more time, and please read slowly to allow everything to sink in, OK? - Audiophilander 23:46:04 12/30/09 (3)
- " They are still great players" - Wendell Narrod 08:57:05 01/01/10 (1)
- RE: " They are still great players" - They are indeed - TK421 18:07:25 01/01/10 (0)
- RE: Lets try this one more time, and please read slowly to allow everything to sink in, OK? - Jazz Inmate 01:32:43 12/31/09 (0)
- 3D support for PS/3 would be great - 4season 11:17:11 12/29/09 (5)
- it will be there - Joe Murphy Jr 19:09:11 12/31/09 (4)
- an url link to the info regarding said limitation, if u please... - jeromelang 07:01:57 01/01/10 (3)
- same restriction for all versions - Joe Murphy Jr 13:22:10 01/01/10 (2)
- Interesting, thanks - 4season 11:15:10 01/02/10 (0)
- thanks for the info - jeromelang 19:39:21 01/01/10 (0)
- Huh? - Harmonia 09:48:41 12/29/09 (3)
- "...what's politics got to do with it?" - There was a BIG debate Outside and JI was a part of it. - Audiophilander 12:21:23 12/29/09 (2)
- Ah, I see. That's why... - Harmonia 14:55:19 12/29/09 (1)
- "there's many things I love about JC's films, but plot and character development aren't among them" Well said - Jazz Inmate 22:43:07 12/29/09 (0)