Video Asylum

After championing a failed format for months, you may not be hitting the points you think you are

12.146.151.254

This Post Has Been Edited by the Author

In Reply to: RE: Not surprisingly, you miss the point. posted by Jack G on February 25, 2008 at 05:05:10

>> People can still watch and enjoy HD DVDs. <<

You can watch and enjoy lots of things that are foolish to buy, even VHS casettes and Laserdiscs. I hear those are selling at a discount too.

>> In fact, with the current sales, its not a bad idea for people to get a movie they really like cheap. <<

You need to think this through. Unless you plan on wasting shelf space on an HD DVD player indefinitely, it is absolutely a waste of money to keep buying HD DVDs. everyone who adopted HD DVD will get a BD player soon, if they haven't already.

>> This idea, that just because HD DVD didn't win the war, so its now unwatchable, is just plain ignorant. <<

when did I say HD DVD is now unwatchable?

>> By all accounts, vinyl is a dead format yet my LPs still play fine. <<

Yes, but more titles have been released on LP than any other format, going back half a century. HD DVD on the other hand died on the vine with barely a year's worth of titles dribbled out, and few of those are even worth mentioning. So: nice try. Your analogy doesn't work. A better analogy might be SACD, but even that had multiple electronics manufacturers behind it and stuck around for several years and it was also a higher-quality approach than its competition which was not the case with HD DVD.

>> Its going to be a VERY long time before any of Universal's or Paramount's HD DVD exclusive titles make it to BD. Hell, Warner has stated that their HD DVD exclusives will be out on BD sometime in the 2008/2009 cycle. I'ld be surprised if Uni and Para were any earlier. <<

That's only a few months away. A few months is not a "very long time". You're advocating throwing money at a dead format even though you know the living format will soon release the titles. That's very strange advice. It was the myopia and instant-gratification-at-a-lower-cost mentality of HD DVD adopters that created problems in the first place by blinding you to the respective merits of the formats. And you're still at it.

There is nothing in the HD DVD catalog that would warrant having two disc players in our racks. That is just complete insanity. Why would someone want to hang onto that machine? Nostalgia?

>> Wait a year or more to pay a high price for the BD version (if it comes at all), or get and enjoy the HD DVD version now. Hmmmmm. <<

More like: waste money and shelf space on a dead format, or put your money toward enjoying the rapidly growing catalog on BD. Heck...put your coasters and doorstop on ebay and you might even get some decent cash for them now, while people like you are still advocating HD DVD.

You are very knowledgeable on many video subjects but the fact is that you spent months giving people bad information and bad advice on HD DVD vs BD and you're still doing it. The best advice is to buy Blu-ray.
-------------
"I have found that if you love life, life will love you back." -Arthur Rubinstein (1887-1982)

Follow Ups: