Films/DVD Asylum

Posted by patrickU (A) on July 30, 2004 at 01:40:33

In Reply to: And coming from a Frenchman, I'm impressed! posted by Chris Garrett on July 29, 2004 at 20:12:06:

I read quite a few reviews in French magazine and the latest one in the " Cahiers du Cinema " which is the very best we have, saying that without having won the Festival price this film would have NOT been even worse to be taken seriously! But now that it have so it must be considered. So they goes...naive, primitive, dilletante, confuse.
Godard said that is not a film but just a discourse.
I did not read one French review ( three or four I must have ) that state it as a good film.
In Germany it looks similar.