Films/DVD Asylum

Posted by centurymantra (A) on January 04, 2005 at 06:30:56

In Reply to: Re: Any source of listings/reviews of DVD's with top-notch audio? posted by TA on January 4, 2005 at 00:06:01:

Thanks for the input. I will check out the avsforum...surprised I hadn't thought about that already.

I did see The Butterfly Effect and was pleasantly surprised by the film and quite enjoyed it (although I did prefer it's kindred spirit 'Donnie Darko'). I watched it prior to having a full surround sound setup and should perhaps check it out again. I was already aware of the Saving Private Ryan soundtrack and probably should revisit that one as well. It's interesting that you mention THX 1138 as that did have one VERY interesting special audio feature. It is possible to view the movie with only the "Theatre of Noise" sound effects track. I flicked this on just for kicks and was amazed at how compelling (and perhaps more interesting) the film was when viewed in this context. This audio track is rather full and provides for a nearly continuous sound-bed. It was still very easy to follow the theme of the film and setting aside the somewhat stilted dialogue allowed the viewer to more openly interpret the film. At the very least, it highlighted Lucas' skill with visual narrative and his shortcomings with regards to dialogue and character development.

It would also be interesting to determine some of the better restorations of old mono soundtracks as well (perhaps Criterion should be commended?) but will continue my search on that note.

Bryan K.,
Music Lover & President-elect of C.C.A.C. (Concerned Citizens Against Cilantro)