Video Asylum

Posted by Jack G (A) on December 05, 2007 at 05:12:35

In Reply to: RE: To be fair, the differences in audio/video are subtle/non-existent to J6P. posted by oscar on December 04, 2007 at 15:36:33

>>>he hasn't had much exposure to the later Blu-ray releases with high bit rate AVC encodes on 50G discs. I've found a number of HD DVD releases to have inconsistent PQ with too many "soft" scenes sometimes intermixed with scenes with superb PQ (though I've seen the same thing with the Blu-ray releases on 25G discs).<<<
You keep saying this, but I really haven't alot of evidence in my BD collection to confirm this. Most in my collection are good, but not exceptional, pretty much comparable to an average HD DVD, which are also good, but not exceptional. Maybe its my collection, due to my taste in movies. Perhaps the BDA is spending all its time and energy on kiddie movies, that I don't watch. I don't see this consistent superiority that you say you do.
Jack