Audio Asylum Thread Printer

Get a view of an entire thread on one page

FAQ / News / Events

Video Asylum

help me understand this

151.200.35.127

In Reply to: RE: pointing fingers posted by Joe Murphy Jr on January 25, 2008 at 20:52:57

Blu-Ray has been out for what, 1 1/2 years now? Did they not know that they would be using DTS-MA? Are they incapable of planning ahead? Why couldn't the BDA tell Fox to hold off on DTS-MA until the CEs could get their act together?

>>>However, rather than upping the processing power to what would have been worse case scenario numbers, they made some poor decisions/estimations.<<<
They appear to do that alot. I confess, I do not understand the logic, unless they just said to hell with our current customers, make them buy another player. This is the kind of thing the BDA does that really pisses me off.

>>>The market will probably see all new players released in Q3/Q4 08 with either bitstreaming, decoding or both re: DTS-HD Master Audio<<<
IOW, everyone has to buy another BD player. Bit streaming alone isn't going to cut it. I'm already on my second BD player, a fact I'm not happy about. I RESENT having to buy another one just because the BDA doesn't have their act together, and I won't do it. For most people, DTS-HD MA is useless, and those discs with it don't have lossless audio. Once again, Blu-ray seems to be showing itself as consumer unfriendly.
Am I missing something?
Jack

Follow Ups:

signals crossed - Joe Murphy Jr 18:31:38 01/26/08 (1)
> > > However, rather than upping the processing power to what would have been worse case scenario numbers, they made some poor decisions/estimations. < < <
They appear to do that alot. I confess, I do not understand the logic, unless they just said to hell with our current customers, make them buy another player. This is the kind of thing the BDA does that really pisses me off.

I was referring to the chip manufacturers (Sigma Designs and Broadcom), both of which make products for HD DVD player manufacturers (aka Toshiba) to use. It had nothing to do with the BDA.

Why couldn't the BDA tell Fox to hold off on DTS-MA until the CEs could get their act together?

Tell them, no: suggest that they use 5.1 PCM, yes. I doubt FOX would have listened, though (they're quite the renegades at that studio). Besides, FOX was probably under the impression that DTS-HD Master Audio decoding/bitstreaming would not be taking so long. Either way, FOX provide a DTS mix for early players and a lossless mix for current players that bitstream and future players that decode/bitstream the codec.

I can't decode (yet) or bitstream DTS-HD Master Audio with my PS3: however, I'm glad FOX encoded their titles with a lossless codec. They could have pulled a Warner Bros or Paramount and encoded their Blu-ray titles with lossy audio (and no way to get lossless audio, an upgrade, from those titles in the future).

IOW, everyone has to buy another BD player.

Only if you want to decode/bitstream DTS-HD Master Audio. Otherwise, you have a usually nice sounding DTS mix to listen to. Besides, going by what many of the HD DVD supporters have been saying for the past year, lossless audio isn't needed anyway.
- Thank you - Jack G 06:18:40 01/27/08 (0)
  > > > I was referring to the chip manufacturers (Sigma Designs and Broadcom), both of which make products for HD DVD player manufacturers (aka Toshiba) to use. It had nothing to do with the BDA. < < <
  OK, I didn't get that. Thanks for clarifying that.
  > > > They could have pulled a Warner Bros or Paramount and encoded their Blu-ray titles with lossy audio < < <
  If you can't decode the lossless, what difference does it make?
  
  > > > Only if you want to decode/bitstream DTS-HD Master Audio. Otherwise, you have a usually nice sounding DTS mix to listen to. Besides, going by what many of the HD DVD supporters have been saying for the past year, lossless audio isn't needed anyway. < < <
  Actually, I'll eventually have to get another player for advanced video profiles anyway. No, I don't care that much about audio. this is more a matter of principle. Having features that no one can use is very user unfriendly.
  Jack
  
  Edits: 01/27/08

Post a Followup:

FAQ

Post a Message!

Forgot Password?

Moniker (Username):
Password (Optional):
	Remember my Moniker & Password (What's this?) Eat Me
E-Mail (Optional):
Subject:

Message:	(Posts are subject to Content Rules)

Optional Link URL:
Optional Link Title:
Optional Image URL:
Upload Image:
E-mail Replies:	Automagically notify you when someone responds.

To view your new posting or follow-up, click on the RELOAD or REFRESH button on your browser.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

The Cable Cooker